Ontario Severance

Wronko v. Western Inventory Service Ltd.

2008 ONCA 327 (CanLII)Court of Appeal for OntarioDecided Wrongful dismissal

Wrongful Dismissal: Unilateral Contract Amendment & 2 Years Pay

Appeal history

Summary

This is an appeal to the Court of Appeal from a trial judge's decision regarding a wrongful dismissal claim arising from a unilateral contract amendment. The employee, a vice-president, refused to sign a new contract that drastically reduced his contractual severance entitlement, and the employer eventually gave an ultimatum that he must accept the change or lose his job. The trial judge dismissed the employee's action, finding that the employer had given reasonable notice of the contract change and that the employee ended the relationship. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, ruling that the employer's ultimatum constituted a termination and that by allowing the employee to continue working while he clearly objected, the employer had acquiesced to the original contract's terms. The employee was awarded his contractual entitlement of two years' pay, less mitigation earnings, leaving $67,795, alongside $6,977 in unpaid vacation pay and substantial indemnity costs.

Lost your job in Ontario?

See the ESA minimum and what Ontario courts have awarded in similar cases.

Calculate your Ontario severance pay

Free, about a minute, no account needed

Outcome

appeal allowed; cross-appeal dismissed; $67,795 damages awarded

Award

two years termination pay ($286,000) less subsequent earnings ($218,205) for $67,795; $6,977 unpaid vacation pay; substantial indemnity costs

Key Factors

  • wrongful dismissal
  • unilateral contract amendment
  • constructive dismissal
  • substantial indemnity costs
  • employment contract interpretation

Related Cases

P. v. Sky Service F.B.O. Inc.

2026 ONSC 5334 (CanLII) · 2026-09-18

Wrongful Dismissal: Appeal Dismissed as Statute-Barred

The Divisional Court dismissed an appeal from a motion judge's decision granting summary judgment to the employer, ruling that the employee's wrongful dismissal claim was statute-barred. The court applied the Limitations Act, 2002, finding that the limitation period began on the date of dismissal and was not postponed by the claimant's misunderstanding of legal significance or by commencing proceedings in the wrong forum.

B. et al. v. Guycan Ltd.

2026 ONSC 5209 (CanLII) · 2026-09-14

Wrongful Dismissal: Employee Status and Unpaid Commissions

This is a merits decision in a wrongful dismissal case involving an individual who worked through a personal corporation. The court determined the individual was an employee rather than an independent contractor, rejected the claim of constructive dismissal, and found that the individual had resigned. The court awarded damages for unpaid statutory public holiday pay and commissions, but found no entitlement to pay in lieu of reasonable notice.

K. v. Crossbridge Condominium Services Ltd.

2026 ONCA 636 (CanLII) · 2026-09-10

Wrongful Dismissal: Successor Liability & Notice Appeal

This is an appeal from a motion judge's decision granting summary judgment for common law reasonable notice and lost benefits in a wrongful dismissal case involving a building services provider. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, upholding the finding that the incoming provider was deemed an employer under the Employment Standards Act, 2000, and confirming the application of statutory interpretation principles to establish successor liability.

A. v. The Chiefs of Ontario

2026 ONSC 5099 (CanLII) · 2026-09-01

This is a procedural ruling regarding the award of substantial indemnity costs in a dispute involving the Chiefs of Ontario. The court considered whether the conduct of the parties warranted such costs, addressing issues of vexatious conduct by a self-represented litigant and the reasonableness of costs at the preliminary motion stage.

H. v. 1359768 Ontario Inc. (B&B Towing)

2026 ONCA 577 (CanLII) · 2026-08-10

Wrongful Dismissal: Frustration & Company Asset Damages

This is an appeal from a wrongful dismissal decision where the Court of Appeal for Ontario dismissed the appeal regarding the issue of frustration of contract. The court found that the employment contract was not frustrated because the employee's essential duties were accommodable and there was a reasonable likelihood of return to work. Additionally, the court reduced the damages award by disallowing compensation for the loss of use of a company tow truck and cellphone, determining these were work tools rather than perquisites.

More Ontario employment decisions from 2008

This summary was written by AI from the published decision and its headnote. It is not an official version of the decision; read the full text on CanLII before relying on it. This is legal information, not legal advice. Ontario Severance is an educational tool. If you are facing a serious employment law matter, consult with a qualified employment lawyer in Ontario.