Re Metropolitan Toronto Police Association and Metropolitan Board of Commissioners of Police
Collective Agreement Dispute: Radio Dispatching and Management Rights
Summary
A labour and employment case involving the interpretation of a collective agreement between the Metropolitan Toronto Police Association and the Metropolitan Board of Commissioners of Police. The dispute centers on whether the radio dispatching duties fall under the collective agreement and whether the arbitrator erred in determining no violation occurred. The case also examines the jurisdiction of arbitrators under the Police Act and the management rights of police commissioners in assigning duties to civilian employees.
Outcome
Arbitrator determined no violation of the agreement and that management retained control over the assignment of duties.
Key Factors
- collective agreements
- scope of agreement
- management rights
- arbitrator jurisdiction
- duties of police officers
Related Cases
Cross v. Cooling Tower Maintenance Inc.
2025 ONSC 7203 (CanLII) · 2025-12-23Employment Contract Dispute: Summary Judgment and Lump Sum Payment
A case involving the interpretation and enforcement of a settlement agreement in an employment context. The court granted summary judgment, finding that the failure to disclose re-employment did not constitute repudiation, and ordered the payment of a lump sum. The court also dismissed a counterclaim for punitive damages.
Barnett v. Canadian Nuclear Laboratories Ltd.
2025 ONSC 6400 (CanLII) · 2025-11-17Employment Contract: Forum Selection Clause Validity and Enforceability
A civil procedure case examining the enforceability of a forum selection clause in an employment contract. The court found the clause valid and enforceable, despite the plaintiff's transition to a new employer and the defendant's arguments for a more appropriate forum in Manitoba.
Liggett v. Veeva Software Systems, Inc. and Veeva Systems Inc.
2025 ONSC 7010 (CanLII) · 2025-10-07Employment Contract Dispute: Termination Clause and Reasonable Notice
A case involving the enforceability of a termination clause under the Employment Standards Act, 2000, and the determination of reasonable notice for a senior product manager. The court also addressed the award of benefits and incentive compensation during the notice period.
McCoubrey v. Salesfloor Inc.
2025 ONSC 3739 (CanLII) · 2025-06-24Employment Contract Case: Commission Policies and Entitlements
A case involving the interpretation of employment agreements and commission policies. The court determined that the 2020 Commission Policy governed the plaintiff's entitlements and that the plaintiff was entitled to $61,228.28 USD in commissions for deals she was the effective cause of before her resignation.
Riva Plumbing Limited v. Ferrari
2025 ONSC 3219 (CanLII) · 2025-05-29Employment Contract Dispute: Pro-Rated Bonuses Awarded
A case involving former employees of a plumbing business who were accused of breaching fiduciary duties and non-competition clauses. The court ruled that there was no breach of duties as the employees did not compete during their employment or misuse confidential information. Additionally, the court determined that the employees were entitled to pro-rated bonuses under oral agreements despite resigning before the fiscal year-end.
This is legal information, not legal advice. Ontario Severance is an educational tool. If you are facing a serious employment law matter, consult with a qualified employment lawyer in Ontario.