Bonus Damages — Ontario Employment Law
Have a question about your own situation?
Ask our AI assistant about Ontario employment law.
Free, no account needed
Related Keywords
About Bonus Damages
When an employee in Ontario is terminated without cause, they are legally entitled to be put in the same financial position they would have enjoyed had they received proper working notice. This foundational principle of wrongful dismissal law forms the basis for "bonus damages." While base salary is the obvious starting point, a frequent legal battleground involves compensating a dismissed worker for the bonuses they would have earned or received during their common law reasonable notice period.
Under Ontario common law, if a bonus forms an integral part of your total compensation package, you are generally entitled to its equivalent value as damages following a termination. This remains true even if the employer labels the payout as "discretionary," provided there is a historical pattern of the bonus being paid regularly based on corporate or individual performance. When courts determine what an employee is owed for reasonable notice (which is based on individual factors like age, length of service, and character of employment, without using a formula), they look at the entire compensation structure, not just the base wage.
A major sticking point in these disputes is restrictive language buried in company policies. Employers frequently draft compensation structures requiring an employee to be in "active employment" on the day the bonus is paid. However, Ontario courts have repeatedly ruled that such language alone is often insufficient to strip an individual of their common law rights. The law treats the reasonable notice period as time the employee should have been actively working. To lawfully deny bonus damages during this period, the contract or bonus plan must contain highly specific language that explicitly ousts this common law entitlement. Furthermore, if any termination provision in the contract violates the minimum standards set out in the Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA), the restrictive bonus language may also be struck down in its entirety.
Because the exact wording of corporate bonus policies, incentive plans, and initial employment contracts profoundly alters your entitlements upon termination, having a knowledgeable legal professional review your specific documents is essential before you sign any severance offer.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are bonus damages in a wrongful dismissal claim?
Bonus damages refer to the financial compensation awarded to a terminated employee for the bonus payments they would have received during their common law reasonable notice period. It ensures the employee is adequately compensated for their total lost income, not just their base salary.
Can my employer deny my bonus if I was fired just before the payout date?
Generally, no. If the bonus is considered an integral part of your compensation, you are typically entitled to the bonus you earned prior to termination, as well as the bonuses you would have earned during your reasonable notice period.
My contract states I must be "actively employed" to receive a bonus. Does this mean I lose it?
Not necessarily. Ontario courts frequently rule that "active employment" clauses are not clear enough to remove your right to common law damages. To deny you this compensation, the contract must explicitly state that bonuses will not be paid during the reasonable notice period.
Are "discretionary" bonuses included when calculating wrongful dismissal damages?
Yes, they often are. If an employer consistently pays a "discretionary" bonus year after year, courts may rule that it is actually a non-discretionary, integral part of the compensation package and award damages for its loss.
How are bonus damages typically calculated by a court?
If a bonus amount fluctuates, courts will often determine damages by calculating an average of the bonuses you received over the previous two to three years, though this can vary depending on individual performance metrics and corporate targets.
When should I consult an employment lawyer about a disputed bonus payout?
You should seek legal advice as soon as you receive a severance offer that excludes your expected bonus, as navigating the complex contractual language governing incentive pay is difficult to do without professional guidance.
Common Scenarios
- A senior executive is terminated without cause three months before annual performance bonuses are distributed, and the employer refuses to pay out the executive's expected portion, citing a strict "active employment" clause in their HR manual.
- A general manager who regularly received a significant "discretionary" bonus every year for the past five years is offered a severance package that only covers base salary and outright excludes any valuation of their incentive pay.
- An employee whose role fundamentally expanded over several years undergoes a "changed substratum" in their employment, rendering their original contract outdated and allowing them to pursue bonus damages despite restrictive wording in their initial agreement.
What You Should Know
- Retain copies of your annual bonus letters, historical pay stubs, and written performance targets to clearly demonstrate your track record of receiving incentive payouts.
- Look beyond your main employment agreement; the language dictating your entitlement to bonus damages might be buried in a separate compensation policy or corporate Code of Conduct.
- Do not assume an employer's verbal claim that a bonus is "purely discretionary" will legally hold up, as consistent historical payouts often prove the opposite.
- Have legal counsel review your entire compensation structure before accepting a severance package, as minor wording nuances can be the difference between losing or recovering thousands of dollars.
Featured Cases
Celestini v. Shoplogix Inc.
2023 ONCA 131 (CanLII) · 2023-02-28Appeal Dismissed: Changed Substratum Doctrine Applies
This is an appeal from a motion judge's decision involving an employee whose role had fundamentally expanded over time. The Court of Appeal upheld the finding that the 'changed substratum' doctrine rendered the termination clause unenforceable, maintaining the 18 months' reasonable notice award. The employee's cross-appeal regarding the deduction of the accrued bonus was allowed in part.
L. v. La Presse (2018) Inc.
2021 ONSC 3506 (CanLII) · 2021-05-21Wrongful Dismissal: General Manager Awarded 6 Months Notice
This was a summary judgment motion in a wrongful dismissal case involving a general manager with five-and-a-half years of service. The court determined the reasonable notice period was eight months but reduced it by two months due to the plaintiff's failure to mitigate damages by delaying his job search. Additionally, the court awarded damages for a lost bonus, finding it was an integral part of the compensation package.
S. v. Norvic Shipping North America
2020 ONSC 8068 (CanLII) · 2020-12-23Wrongful Dismissal: Senior Executive Awarded 8 Months Notice
This wrongful dismissal case concerned a senior executive with nearly four years of service whose termination clause was found unenforceable for potentially violating minimum employment standards under the Canada Labour Code and Ontario Employment Standards Act. The court applied the Bardal factors to determine that eight months' notice was reasonable and awarded damages for discretionary bonuses deemed integral to compensation.
Paquette v. TeraGo Networks Inc.
2016 ONCA 618 (CanLII) · 2016-08-09Wrongful Dismissal: Bonus Damages During 17-Month Notice
The Court of Appeal for Ontario heard an appeal regarding a wrongful dismissal claim where the employee was terminated without cause. The central issue was whether the employee was entitled to damages for lost bonuses during the reasonable notice period, specifically examining whether an 'active employment' condition in the bonus plan effectively limited common law rights. The court held that the clause was insufficient to restrict these rights and awarded damages for bonuses the employee would have earned during the 17-month notice period.
L. v. Ontario Teachers' Pension Plan
2016 ONCA 619 (CanLII) · 2016-08-09Wrongful Dismissal: 15 Months Notice and Bonus Damages
This appeal concerns a wrongful dismissal case involving an employee terminated without cause who was awarded 15 months' notice. The Court of Appeal upheld the trial judge's determination of the notice period and the award of damages for lost bonuses, finding no error in the interpretation of the employment contract and the employer's Code of Business Conduct.
B. v. Nygard International Partnership
2013 ONCA 780 (CanLII) · 2013-12-20Wrongful Dismissal: 18 Months Notice Awarded
The Court of Appeal for Ontario dismissed an appeal from a motion judge's summary judgment decision in a wrongful dismissal case. The court upheld the finding that an alleged amending employment agreement did not raise a genuine issue for trial and confirmed the award of 18 months' pay in lieu of notice plus damages for a 2013 bonus. The court also upheld the imposition of a trust on mitigation income, finding no error in the motion judge's assessment of the employee's seniority, specialized experience, and the bonus as integral to compensation.
D. v. MMV Financial Inc.
2012 ONSC 7257 (CanLII) · 2012-12-19Wrongful Dismissal: 12 Months Notice for Senior Executive
This wrongful dismissal case involved a senior executive terminated without cause after nearly four years of employment. The court applied the Bardal factors to determine a reasonable notice period of 12 months and awarded damages for lost bonus income using a historical averaging method. The court also addressed mitigation efforts, special damages for lost benefits, and a dismissed claim for unvested stock options.