Ontario Severance

Grievance — Ontario Employment Law

18 casesDecisions from 1967–2025

Have a question about your own situation?

Ask our AI assistant about Ontario employment law.

Ask a question

Free, no account needed

About Grievance

In Ontario employment law, a "grievance" is a formal workplace complaint asserting that an employer has violated the terms of a collective agreement or applicable employment legislation. While non-unionized workers often use the terms "complaint" or "grievance" loosely, in the legal context, a grievance specifically refers to the formal dispute resolution mechanism utilized in unionized environments governed by statutes like the Ontario Labour Relations Act, 1995 (OLRA) or the statutory frameworks for specific public sector workers, such as the Police Services Act.

The most critical legal principle surrounding grievances in Ontario is the concept of "exclusive jurisdiction." If an employee is part of a unionized bargaining unit, the grievance process outlined in their collective agreement is almost always the exclusive avenue for resolving workplace disputes. This includes disputes about termination, discipline, wage calculations, and even violations of statutory rights under the Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA) or the Ontario Human Rights Code (OHRC).

Ontario civil courts consistently rule that they do not have the jurisdiction to hear disputes that arise out of the interpretation, application, or violation of a collective agreement. When unionized employees attempt to bypass the grievance system and sue their employer for wrongful dismissal or breach of contract in civil court, employers will typically file a procedural motion to strike the pleadings. Unless the issue falls completely outside the employment relationship, the court will dismiss the lawsuit, directing the employee back to the grievance and arbitration process.

Grievances generally fall into three categories: individual grievances (affecting one employee), group grievances (affecting a specific subset of employees), and policy grievances (filed by the union itself regarding broad interpretive issues affecting the whole bargaining unit). Because labour relations disputes are inherently unique, determining whether a specific dispute must be grieved or can be litigated in court is a highly specialized area of law. Any worker unsure about which legal avenue applies to their situation should consult a qualified legal professional to assess their specific employment status and jurisdictional options.

Frequently Asked Questions

I am in a union. Can I sue my employer in civil court instead of filing a grievance?

Generally, no. Ontario courts operate under an "exclusive jurisdiction" model for unionized employment. If your dispute arises from the workplace or your collective agreement, the court will likely dismiss your lawsuit and require you to use the grievance process outlined in your union contract.

What kind of workplace issues can be addressed through a formal grievance?

A grievance can address direct violations of the collective agreement (such as improper pay, denied seniority, or unjustified discipline) as well as violations of employment-related legislation like the Ontario Human Rights Code or the Occupational Health and Safety Act (OHSA).

How long do I have to file a grievance against my employer in Ontario?

The time limit is not general to all of Ontario; it is strictly dictated by the specific wording in your collective agreement. Deadlines can be as short as a few days, and failing to file within this timeframe can result in a fatal procedural failure that bars your claim.

What happens if my union refuses to file a grievance on my behalf?

If your union assesses your complaint and decides not to file a grievance, you still cannot sue your employer in civil court. However, if you believe the union acted in a manner that was arbitrary, discriminatory, or in bad faith, you may be able to file a "Duty of Fair Representation" application with the Ontario Labour Relations Board.

Are non-unionized employees able to file formal grievances?

In strict legal terms, "grievances" apply to unionized workplaces under collective agreements. If you are non-unionized, you would instead pursue your rights by filing a civil claim in court or lodging a formal complaint with the Ontario Ministry of Labour.

Should I hire a lawyer to help with my grievance?

Typically, your union representative or union-retained legal counsel handles grievance filings and representation. However, retaining independent legal counsel is a smart step if you need help determining if your specific issue falls outside the collective agreement's jurisdiction, or if you are considering a related action against your union.

Common Scenarios

  • A unionized public sector worker attempts to sue their employer for constructive dismissal in Superior Court, and the employer immediately brings a motion to strike the civil claim on the basis that the court lacks jurisdiction over matters properly subject to a grievance.
  • An employee notices that their shift premiums were calculated incorrectly for three consecutive pay periods, prompting them to initiate an individual grievance by speaking with their union steward.
  • A worker delays reporting an unfair disciplinary suspension by one month, only to discover their collective agreement required all grievances to be filed within 10 days, causing the employer to dismiss the grievance on procedural grounds.
  • A union files a policy grievance on behalf of the entire bargaining unit after the employer unilaterally implements a mandatory new attendance tracking app that the union argues violates workplace privacy norms under the contract.

What You Should Know

  • Always secure a current copy of your collective agreement; your rights, mandatory procedural steps, and specific deadlines for initiating a grievance are explicitly detailed in its pages.
  • Never delay in bringing a workplace issue to your union representative's attention, as missing a collective agreement timeline is a frequent procedural failure that can completely invalidate your claim.
  • Do not spend money filing a civil court claim before confirming your employment status; if your job is governed by a collective agreement, civil courts in Ontario will routinely redirect you to the grievance mechanism.
  • Keep meticulous records of the incident, including related emails, paystubs, and witness names, to provide your union with the necessary evidence to successfully draft and escalate your grievance.
  • If you are confused about whether your human rights or health and safety complaint belongs in a grievance or at an external tribunal, seeking an independent consultation with a labour lawyer can clarify the jurisdictional boundaries.

Featured Cases

B. v. V.

2025 ONSC 5800 (CanLII) · 2025-10-14

Jurisdiction: Federal Labour Act vs Small Claims Court

This is an appeal to the Divisional Court regarding a motion to strike a defamation claim arising from workplace matters. The court addressed whether the Federal Public Sector Labour Relations Act ousts the jurisdiction of the Small Claims Court in favor of the grievance process, and also considered motions for fresh evidence and ineffective assistance of counsel.

civil procedure defamation grievance jurisdiction labour relations

W. et al v. Durham Regional Police Service et al

2024 ONSC 2309 (CanLII) · 2024-04-19

This is a procedural ruling regarding a motion to strike pleadings in a labour law dispute involving collective agreements and grievances under the Police Services Act.

collective agreements grievance labour law striking pleadings

R.G. v. Agropur Cooperative

2018 ONSC 1966 (CanLII) · 2018-03-23

This is a procedural ruling concerning jurisdiction in a labour law dispute involving collective agreements and grievances under the Ontario Labour Relations Act, 1995.

collective agreements grievance jurisdiction labour relations

B. v. G.

2015 ONCA 161 (CanLII) · 2015-03-12

B. v. G.: PSSRA Bars Defamation Claim

This is an appeal to the Court of Appeal from a summary judgment. The employee sued his former employer, the National Research Council, and individual employees for defamation based on a document summarizing the reasons for his termination. The motion judge dismissed the claim, finding it was barred by the exclusive grievance scheme under the Public Service Staff Relations Act, failed to establish defamation, and was protected by qualified privilege. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, agreeing that the defamation claim could not circumvent the statutory grievance procedure and finding no error in the alternative conclusions.

defamation exclusive remedy grievance pssra termination

K. v. Canada (Attorney General)

2014 ONSC 5928 (CanLII) · 2014-10-10

A case involving a self-represented litigant concerning the failure to file a grievance within the public sector employment dispute resolution process.

employment dispute grievance procedural failure public sector

K. v. City of Ottawa

2013 ONSC 1032 (CanLII) · 2013-02-14

A labour law case concerning the interpretation of a collective agreement and the grievance process, decided via a procedural motion under Rule 21.

civil procedure collective agreements grievance labour relations

T. v. (Canada) Attorney General

2012 ONSC 484 (CanLII) · 2012-01-27

Public Servant Jurisdiction: PSLRA s. 236 & Limitations

This is a judicial review of a tribunal decision concerning the jurisdiction of the Superior Court over a former public servant's claim for reimbursement of pool maintenance costs. The court addressed whether section 236 of the Public Service Labour Relations Act ousted its jurisdiction and whether the claim was statute-barred under the Limitations Act, ultimately upholding jurisdiction in unique circumstances where the grievance procedure was unavailable.

grievance jurisdiction labour relations limitation periods public service

Carleton University v. Carleton University Academic Staff Association

2011 ONSC 5869 (CanLII) · 2011-10-05

A judicial review application concerning labour relations and grievances between Carleton University and the Carleton University Academic Staff Association.

administrative law grievance judicial review labour relations

Teamsters Local Union No. 230 v. Dufferin Concrete

2011 ONSC 1032 (CanLII) · 2011-02-14

Judicial Review: Union Grievance Dismissed for Delay

This is a judicial review proceeding concerning an arbitrator's dismissal of a union grievance due to delay in advancing the grievance under the collective agreement. The Divisional Court upheld the arbitrator's decision as reasonable and found no denial of natural justice, ultimately dismissing the application for judicial review due to delay in perfecting the application.

arbitration collective agreements grievance judicial review labour relations

B. v. Canada (Attorney General)

2010 ONCA 71 (CanLII) · 2010-01-29

Federal Civil Servant: Grievance Process Exclusive Jurisdiction

This is a procedural ruling on jurisdiction involving a federal civil servant who brought tort claims in the Superior Court for workplace mistreatment and whistle-blower retaliation. The Court of Appeal for Ontario determined whether section 236 of the Public Service Labour Relations Act ousted the Superior Court's jurisdiction in favor of the exclusive grievance process. The court interpreted the statute to find that the grievance process is the exclusive forum for such workplace disputes, including whistle-blower complaints.

grievance jurisdiction labour relations public service whistle-blower

J.D.E. v. Hamilton Police Services Board

2009 CanLII 70134 (ON SC) · 2009-12-14

This is a procedural motion regarding jurisdiction in a labour and employment dispute involving the Hamilton Police Services Board. The court addressed whether it had grievance jurisdiction under the Police Services Act.

grievance jurisdiction labour relations police services act

J. v. Ontario (Ministry of Community, Family and Children's Services)

2005 CanLII 8187 (ON CA) · 2005-03-29

J. v. Ontario: Jurisdiction Over Grievance Settlements

This is an appeal to the Court of Appeal from an order of a motion judge. The employee challenged a settlement reached before the Grievance Settlement Board. The court below found it lacked jurisdiction and dismissed the action. The Court of Appeal upheld this decision, ruling that challenges to such settlements are matters for the Board, even if the employee's union will not support her.

labour relations jurisdiction collective agreements grievance duty of fair representation

M. v. F.

2004 CanLII 60018 (ON CA) · 2004-02-23

This is an appeal to the Court of Appeal from a motion judge's decision dismissing an employee's claim. The employee sued the defendant after failing to obtain a remedy through her employer's complaint and grievance procedures. The motion judge struck the claim under the rules of civil procedure. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, agreeing that permitting the court claim to proceed would be an abuse of process. The dismissal of the civil claim stands.

civil procedure grievance indemnity costs labour relations

O.P.S.E.U. v. Fanshawe College of Applied Arts and Technology

1994 CanLII 10985 (ON CTGDDC) · 1994-02-21

A judicial review of an arbitration decision involving a collective agreement and grievances between a union and an employer.

arbitration collective agreements grievance labour relations

Fanshawe College of Applied Arts & Technology v. O.P.S.E.U.

1990 CanLII 8052 (ON HCJDC) · 1990-05-10

Arbitration Jurisdiction: Workload Disputes Under Collective Agreement

This is a judicial review of an arbitration board's decision concerning a union grievance under a collective agreement. The Divisional Court set aside the arbitration board's decision for lack of jurisdiction, determining that workload disputes were governed by specific collective agreement articles that excluded them from the general grievance procedure.

arbitration collective agreements grievance labour relations workload

Re Communications Union Canada and Bell Canada Re Bell Canada and Communications Union Canada

1976 CanLII 839 (ON SC) · 1976-10-15

Arbitration Jurisdiction: Union vs Bell Canada

This is a judicial review of an arbitration board's decision regarding its jurisdiction to hear grievances filed by the Communications Union Canada against Bell Canada. The central issue is whether the employer was estopped from challenging the board's jurisdiction after arbitration had commenced, and whether the grievances should have been treated as individual or policy grievances under the collective agreement.

arbitration collective agreements estoppel grievance labour relations

Re Municipality of Metropolitan Toronto and Toronto Civic Employees' Union, Local 43 et al.

1974 CanLII 722 (ON HCJDC) · 1974-02-21

Arbitrability: Failure to Meet Collective Agreement Time Limits

A labour relations case concerning whether a union's failure to comply with a collective agreement's 15-day time limit for requesting the Minister of Labour to appoint an arbitrator rendered the grievance non-arbitrable. The Board of arbitration held that it could not substitute a 'reasonable time' for the specific contractual limit and that the statutory power of the Minister did not override this failure.

arbitration collective agreements grievance labour relations time-limits

Union Carbide Canada Ltd. v. W. et al.

1967 CanLII 38 (ON CA) · 1967-10-10

This is a judicial review application challenging a board of arbitration's determination that a grievance was arbitrable under the Labour Relations Act. The Court of Appeal for Ontario held that the board's decision on arbitrability was a question of law within its jurisdiction and not subject to judicial review. This decision was appealed to the Supreme Court of Canada, which reversed it (Union Carbide Canada Ltd. v. W. et al., [1968] SCR 966). The Supreme Court allowed the appeal and quashed the decision of the board of arbitration. The board had no power to extend the time limit for the grievance.

arbitration grievance judicial review labour relations