Ontario Severance

Pension Surplus — Ontario Employment Law

16 casesDecisions from 1984–2010

Have a question about your own situation?

Ask our AI assistant about Ontario employment law.

Ask a question

Free, no account needed

About Pension Surplus

In Ontario employment and trust law, a "pension surplus" arises when a defined benefit pension plan holds more assets than are necessary to cover its current and future liabilities to members. Essentially, the investments have performed well, or the demographic expectations have shifted, leaving extra money in the fund. While this sounds like a positive scenario, pension surpluses frequently become a significant source of legal conflict between employers, unions, active employees, and retirees.

The core legal dispute usually centres on who is entitled to the surplus funds once members' defined benefits are fully secured. Employers typically argue that because they bore the financial risk of funding the plan and ensuring its solvency during downturns, they should be entitled to any leftover funds (a concept known as "surplus reversion"). Conversely, employees and retirees often argue that pension funds are held in trust exclusively for the beneficiaries, meaning any excess should be distributed to them as enhanced benefits or cash payouts.

In Ontario, these rights are largely governed by the Pension Benefits Act (PBA) and the strict interpretation of the pension plan's historical trust documents. The PBA establishes high statutory hurdles that an employer must clear to withdraw surplus cash, especially during a plan wind-up. Even if the current plan text allows the employer to take the surplus, the courts will look backward through decades of plan amendments to see if the original trust agreement established an "exclusive benefit" clause that irrevocably locked the funds in favour of the employees. If an employer breached its trust obligations by improperly claiming or manipulating surplus funds during corporate restructurings or employee transfers, the courts may intervene.

Because the rules surrounding pension surpluses intertwine strict statutory schemes with centuries-old common law trust principles, outcomes vary wildly depending on the precise historical wording of the applicable plan. Resolving these complex financial ownership questions involves intense document review and specialized statutory interpretation, so individuals or retiree groups facing a plan wind-up or surplus distribution proposal should seek legal guidance from a trained professional to understand their precise entitlements.

Frequently Asked Questions

What exactly is a pension surplus?

A pension surplus occurs in a defined benefit pension plan when the actuarial value of the plan's assets is greater than the total value of the pensions it is obligated to pay out. The surplus represents the "extra" funds left over after accounting for all liabilities.

Does the employer automatically get to keep the surplus?

No. Under Ontario's Pension Benefits Act, an employer must meet strict procedural and legal requirements to claim a surplus. They must prove that the original trust documents and plan texts expressly allow the funds to revert to the employer.

Can my employer use a surplus to stop making pension contributions?

Sometimes. This is called a "contribution holiday." Under the PBA, if a plan has a sufficient actuarial surplus, an employer may be permitted to suspend their regular contributions and use the surplus to cover the cost of current pension accruals, provided the plan text permits it.

What happens to the surplus if a company closes and the pension plan winds up?

During a plan wind-up, the Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (FSRA) oversees the distribution of assets. If there is a surplus, it may be subject to a surplus-sharing agreement negotiated between the employer and the members, or its ownership may have to be decided by the courts based on trust law.

If my workplace transfers me to a new pension plan, do my surplus entitlements follow?

This depends heavily on the terms of the transfer, the collective agreement (if applicable), and fiduciary law. Courts have sometimes found that transferring employees are entitled to have a proportional share of the surplus transferred to their new plan to protect their reasonable expectations.

When should our retiree group consult a legal professional about a pension surplus?

You should engage an employment or pension lawyer immediately if your employer announces a plan wind-up, applies to the regulator to withdraw surplus funds, or proposes a surplus-sharing agreement, as these situations permanently affect your financial rights.

Common Scenarios

  • A manufacturing plant shuts down permanently, triggering a full wind-up of its defined benefit pension plan, which reveals a $12 million surplus that both the insolvent employer's liquidator and the retirees claim ownership of.
  • A corporation sells off one of its divisions to a buyer. The transferred employees demand that a proportional slice of the historical pension surplus be transferred into their newly established pension trust.
  • An employer proposes a "surplus-sharing agreement" where they offer to distribute 40% of an existing plan surplus to active and retired members in exchange for the members consenting to the employer withdrawing the remaining 60%.
  • Current employees discover that their employer has taken a "contribution holiday" for five years, using a plan surplus to fund the employer's matching obligations rather than using company revenues, prompting a dispute over plan interpretation.

What You Should Know

  • Keep old copies of your pension plan booklets, annual statements, and enrollment forms; historical wording from decades ago often proves crucial in determining who legally owns a surplus today.
  • Pay close attention to any mail you receive from your employer or the Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (FSRA) regarding plan amendments or wind-ups, as there are strict objection periods.
  • If you are part of a massive corporate restructuring, push for a joint or representative committee of active members and retirees, as grouping together gives you the resources to fund complex actuarial and legal reviews.
  • Do not sign a surplus-sharing agreement or consent form without having the document independently reviewed by a lawyer who understands Ontario pension trust litigation.

Featured Cases

M. and G. v. Canada Mortgage and Housing

2010 ONSC 65 (CanLII) · 2010-06-16

Pension Class Action: Certification Appeal

This is an appeal from a certification decision in a class action concerning the partial termination of a pension plan and ownership of pension fund surplus. The Divisional Court reviewed the certification judge's refusal to certify certain common issues, finding that individual issues overwhelmed commonality and that the court lacked jurisdiction to order partial termination directly.

class action certification employment benefits judicial review pension plans pension surplus

S. v. Hudson's Bay Company

2009 CanLII 43661 (ON SC) · 2009-08-20

Pension Surplus Dispute: S. v. Hudson's Bay

This is a legal dispute concerning the distribution of surplus funds within a pension plan between the employer and the employees. The case addresses the legal rights and entitlements regarding pension plan surpluses under the relevant pension legislation.

employment benefits pension legislation pension plans pension surplus

B. v. Hudson's Bay Company

2008 ONCA 690 (CanLII) · 2008-10-10

B. v. Hudson's Bay Company - Costs Decision

This is a costs decision of the Court of Appeal for Ontario following an earlier appeal decision. In the main appeal, the court allowed the employer's appeal and dismissed the representative plaintiffs' cross-appeal regarding entitlement to pension surplus for transferred employees. The parties could not agree on costs. The court decided that the costs of both parties should be paid from the pension fund on a full indemnity basis, fixing the appeal costs and remitting the trial costs to the trial judge for assessment.

pension plans pension surplus costs award class action costs

B. v. Hudson's Bay Company

2005 CanLII 47086 (ON SC) · 2005-12-16

Pension Surplus: Breach of Trust in Transfer

This case addresses whether an employer breached its fiduciary and trust obligations by failing to transfer a proportional share of pension surplus to a new plan upon the transfer of employees. The court found a breach of trust and ordered a restitutionary remedy to reflect the reasonable expectations of the transferred employees, while also validating certain administrative deductions permitted by plan amendments. The case later reached the Supreme Court of Canada (B. v. Hudson's Bay Co., 2010 SCC 34). The Supreme Court affirmed the Court of Appeal's decision, finding that the Hudson's Bay Company was not obligated to transfer a portion of the pension plan's actuarial surplus to the transferred employees, and that it properly charged plan administration expenses to the pension fund. The transferred employees' rights were limited to their defined benefits, which were adequately protected in the transfer to the new employer's pension plan.

breach of trust equitable remedies fiduciary duties pension plans pension surplus

Monsanto Canada Inc. v. Ontario (Superintendent of Financial Services)

2002 CanLII 17842 (ON CA) · 2002-11-22

Monsanto Canada Inc. Pension Surplus Distribution Decision

This is an appeal to the Court of Appeal from a decision of the Divisional Court regarding the partial wind up of a pension plan. The employer, Monsanto Canada Inc., sought to partially wind up its defined benefit pension plan without distributing the actuarial surplus to the affected members. The Divisional Court decided that section 70(6) of the Pension Benefits Act requires the distribution of surplus to affected members on a partial wind up, setting aside the Financial Services Tribunal's majority decision. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, holding that the Divisional Court correctly applied the reasonableness standard and that the employer's interpretation of the Act was unreasonable.

administrative law pension benefits pension benefits act pension surplus pensions standard of review statutory interpretation surplus funds

Police Retirees of Ontario Incorporated v. Ontario Municipal Employees' Retirement Board

2000 CanLII 16902 (ON CA) · 2000-10-05

Police Retirees v. OMERS: Pension Surplus Entitlement

This is an appeal concerning whether police retirees are entitled to excess pension funds (surplus) under the Pension Benefits Act and trust law principles. The court addressed arguments based on the 'deferred wages' theory and whether defined benefit plans create a trust interest in surplus funds for retirees.

deferred wages pension surplus retiree entitlement statutory interpretation trust principles

H. v. Howden Group Canada Limited

1999 CanLII 3703 (ON CA) · 1999-03-10

Pension Surplus: Trust vs Contract Principles

This is an appeal concerning the distribution of surplus funds from a pension plan, specifically addressing whether the plan created an irrevocable trust or was governed by contract principles. The Court of Appeal for Ontario applied trust law and statutory interpretation to determine that the 1973 amendment validly allocated the surplus to the employer.

employer rights pension plans pension surplus schmidt v. air products trust law

L. v. Deloro Stellite

1993 CanLII 9418 (ON CA) · 1993-01-12

Pension Surplus Appeal: L. v. Deloro Stellite

An appeal to the Court of Appeal for Ontario concerning the distribution of surplus in a pension plan. The decision addresses legal issues related to pension surplus allocation.

appeal employment benefits pension surplus plan administration

Otis Canada Inc. v. Ontario (Superintendent of Pensions) (Gen. Div.)

1991 CanLII 7270 (ON SC) · 1991-02-25

Pension Surplus Reversion: Otis Canada v. Ontario

This is a judicial review or declaratory judgment proceeding regarding the entitlement of an employer to surplus funds in a non-contributory pension plan upon wind-up. The court examined whether the Pension Benefits Act, 1987, and the specific plan text allowed for the reversion of surplus funds to the employer after all member liabilities were satisfied. The decision focused on statutory interpretation of the surplus reversion clause and trust law principles regarding the vesting of pension funds.

pension benefits act pension surplus plan interpretation surplus reversion trust law

A. v. Ontario Hospital Association (C.A.)

1991 CanLII 7232 (ON CA) · 1991-02-20

Pension Surplus Use: A. v. Ontario Hospital Association

This is an appeal to the Court of Appeal for Ontario concerning the use of surplus in a defined benefit pension plan. The central issue was whether the employer association was entitled to reduce its contributions based on the plan's surplus and whether doing so breached fiduciary duties or statutory requirements under the Pension Benefits Act.

employer contributions fiduciary duties labour relations pension benefits act pension surplus

O'Brien Leasing Co. v. London Life Insurance Co.

1990 CanLII 8058 (ON SC) · 1990-06-20

Pension Surplus Reversion Dismissed

An employer applied for a refund of pension surplus after a plan wind-up, arguing that the plan and governing legislation allowed for surplus reversion. The court dismissed the application, finding that the statutory conditions under the Pension Benefits Act, 1987 were unmet and the contract language was insufficient to authorize surplus reversion to the employer.

contract interpretation costs pension benefits act pension surplus surplus reversion

C.U.P.E.-C.L.C., Local 1000 v. Ontario Hydro (Ont. C.A.)

1989 CanLII 4209 (ON CA) · 1989-05-03

C.U.P.E. v. Ontario Hydro: Pension Contribution Holiday

This is an appeal concerning the interpretation of statutory pension legislation and the employer's obligation to contribute to the Ontario Hydro pension plan. The central legal issue is whether the employer can unilaterally take a contribution holiday to utilize a surplus in the pension fund, or if such contributions are mandatory under the Power Corporation Act and the Pension Benefits Act.

employer contributions labour relations pension plans pension surplus statutory interpretation

C.A.W., Local 458 v. White Farm Manufacturing Canada Ltd. (H.C.J.)

1989 CanLII 4128 (ON SC) · 1989-01-23

Pension Surplus: Union Entitlement in Receivership

This is a costs ruling in a dispute concerning employee entitlements to surplus funds in a defined benefit pension plan funded solely by the employer. The court addressed whether the surplus formed part of the trust fund and upheld the certainty of the trust, confirming employees were entitled to the surplus. Costs were awarded to all parties out of the pension fund on a solicitor-and-client basis.

costs award employee entitlements labour relations pension surplus trust fund

C.A.W., Local 458 v. White Farm Manufacturing Canada Ltd. (H.C.J.)

1988 CanLII 4774 (ON SC) · 1988-09-08

Pension Surplus: Union vs Employer Trust Dispute

This case addresses whether surplus funds from a defined benefit pension plan, negotiated as part of a collective agreement, belong to the employer or the employees upon wind-up. The court upheld the trust created by the plan, rejecting the employer's claim to the surplus under the resulting trust doctrine and ruling that the funds enure to the employees' benefit.

collective agreements employee entitlements pension surplus trust law

Re R. et al. and Montreal Trust Co. of Canada et al.

1986 CanLII 2516 (ON CA) · 1986-02-20

Pension Surplus: Employer Cannot Revoke Trust

This appeal addresses whether an employer can unilaterally amend a pension plan to revoke a trust and claim surplus funds upon plan discontinuance. The court determined that the employer lacked the authority to revoke the trust or eliminate employees' rights to surplus funds, as contributions were irrevocable and the settlor had not expressly reserved the power to revoke.

beneficial interest employer amendments pension surplus plan discontinuance trust law

C. et al. v. Ferrco Engineering Ltd. et al.

1984 CanLII 5978 (ON SC) · 1984-02-15

This is a substantive dispute concerning the entitlement to surplus assets in a discontinued pension plan. The court addressed whether the surplus belonged to the employer or the employees, interpreting plan provisions and statutory requirements under the Pension Benefits Act.

benefit entitlement employer obligations pension surplus plan termination statutory interpretation