Ontario Severance

Union — Ontario Employment Law

132 casesDecisions from 1924–2026

Have a question about your own situation?

Ask our AI assistant about Ontario employment law.

Ask a question

Free, no account needed

About Union

A common misconception among workers in Ontario is that anyone who loses their job or faces mistreatment can simply hire a lawyer and sue their employer in civil court. However, when a workplace is unionized, the legal landscape shifts dramatically. Under Ontario's Labour Relations Act, a union acts as the exclusive bargaining agent for all employees within its bargaining unit. This means that individual employment contracts are replaced by a collective agreement negotiated between the union and the employer.

Because the union holds this exclusive authority, unionized employees generally cannot sue their employers in civil court for standard employment disputes, such as wrongful dismissal or constructive dismissal. Instead, these conflicts must almost always be resolved through the grievance and arbitration process outlined in the collective agreement. In legal terms, this creates ongoing battles over "jurisdiction." Ontario courts routinely dismiss civil lawsuits filed by unionized workers because the courts lack the authority to intervene in matters that arise from the collective agreement.

That said, the courts are not completely closed to union members. As seen in various Ontario legal disputes, civil courts may retain jurisdiction over specific, non-employment-related torts or internal union conflicts. For example, if a former union president is defamed by a current union executive, or if there is a severe breach of trust obligations, the civil courts may step in to resolve the matter. These cases frequently involve preliminary legal motions to determine exactly where the boundaries of the court's jurisdiction end and the union arbitrator's authority begins.

While unionized workers enjoy the collective strength and structured representation their union provides, they also give up the ability to negotiate their own individual severance packages or immediately litigate against their employer. Disentangling whether a specific workplace conflict belongs in front of a labour arbitrator, the Ontario Labour Relations Board, or an Ontario judge is highly technical. Navigating these overlapping jurisdictions is complex, making it crucial to have an independent legal professional evaluate the unique details of your dispute before deciding how to proceed.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I sue my employer for severance pay if I belong to a union?

Generally, no. As a unionized employee, your severance and termination rights are governed by your collective agreement and the Employment Standards Act (ESA). Any dispute over termination must be handled through your union's grievance procedure, not by filing a lawsuit in an Ontario civil court.

Can I hire an independent employment lawyer if I am unionized?

Yes, you can hire a lawyer for independent legal advice to understand your rights, human rights protections, or WSIB claims. However, an independent lawyer usually cannot bypass the union to directly negotiate your severance or represent you in a standard grievance against your employer.

What happens if I have a legal dispute with the union itself?

If your union refuses to file a grievance or represents you unfairly, you can file a 'Duty of Fair Representation' complaint with the Ontario Labour Relations Board. In rare cases involving personal wrongs—like defamation by a union official—you might be able to bring a civil claim in court.

How long do I have to challenge a disciplinary action if I am in a union?

Unionized environments operate on extremely strict deadlines. Your collective agreement will outline the exact timeframe you have to file a grievance—sometimes as short as 5 to 10 days. Failing to meet this window can permanently extinguish your right to challenge the employer's decision.

If my workplace is unionized, does the Employment Standards Act still apply to me?

Yes, the ESA's minimum standards apply to unionized workers, and a collective agreement cannot provide less than these basic rights. However, enforcement of these ESA minimums is typically handled by the union through the grievance process rather than direct claims to the Ministry of Labour.

Common Scenarios

  • A recently terminated warehouse worker attempts to sue their former company for common law severance in Ontario Small Claims Court, only to have the employer successfully strike the claim because the worker is part of a certified bargaining unit.
  • A former union president pursues a civil defamation lawsuit against the current union executive over damaging statements published in a newsletter, arguing the dispute falls outside the collective agreement.
  • A public sector employee seeks independent legal counsel to verify if their union is meeting its legal obligations during a complex accommodation dispute involving the Ontario Human Rights Code.
  • Two competing construction unions face off in a jurisdictional dispute over which entity has the legal right to represent laborers at a major new infrastructure project.

What You Should Know

  • Always secure a copy of your current collective agreement and pay close attention to the grievance procedure deadlines, as missing a filing window by even one day can be fatal to your case.
  • Keep meticulous written records of your communications with union stewards or representatives, especially if you feel they are dismissing your concerns or refusing to file a grievance on your behalf.
  • If you are considering taking legal action against your union or employer in civil court, have an independent lawyer assess the 'jurisdiction' issue first to avoid paying legal costs for a dismissed claim.
  • Remember that the union owns the grievance; they get to decide whether to push your case to arbitration based on their assessment of its merits and the broader interests of the bargaining unit.

Featured Cases

B. v. ATU Local 113

2026 ONSC 3441 (CanLII) · 2026-06-15

A judicial review application concerning a unionized employee's attempt to bypass the union and seek relief for an unfair labour practice complaint. The Divisional Court refused an extension of time due to an eighteen-month delay and found the employee lacked standing to seek judicial review where the union had declined to act, considering the deference owed to labour arbitrators.

extension of time judicial review labour relations standing union

C. v. Customs and Immigration Union

2025 ONSC 1719 (CanLII) · 2025-03-18

A labour relations case involving the Customs and Immigration Union concerning the jurisdiction of courts in administrative law matters.

administrative law jurisdiction labour relations union

Metrolinx v. Amalgamated Transit Union, Local 1587

2024 ONSC 1900 (CanLII) · 2024-04-02

This is a judicial review proceeding concerning a grievance arbitration award in a labour relations dispute. The Divisional Court reviewed the arbitration decision involving Metrolinx and the Amalgamated Transit Union, Local 1587.

grievance arbitration judicial review labour relations union

Canadian Pacific Railway Company v. Teamsters Canada Rail Conference

2023 ONSC 2928 (CanLII) · 2023-05-17

Judicial Review: Labour Relations Delay & Standard

This is a judicial review of a labour relations tribunal decision involving the Canadian Pacific Railway Company and the Teamsters Canada Rail Conference. The Divisional Court addressed procedural issues including the standard of review, extensions of time, and dismissal for delay, ultimately dismissing the motion to review.

dismissal for delay judicial review labour relations standard of review union

Canadian Union of Public Employees, Local 79 v. City of Toronto

2023 ONSC 2031 (CanLII) · 2023-03-30

A labour relations matter involving the Canadian Union of Public Employees, Local 79 and the City of Toronto concerning a contempt of court order.

contempt employer labour relations union

J. v. Ontario Secondary School Teachers’ Federation

2023 ONSC 59 (CanLII) · 2023-01-05

Judicial Review: Union Duty of Fair Representation

This is a judicial review application concerning the Ontario Labour Relations Board's dismissal of a complaint against the Ontario Secondary School Teachers’ Federation for breach of the duty of fair representation. The Divisional Court assessed the reasonableness of the Board's decisions regarding summary dismissal for delay and failure to establish a prima facie case.

duty of fair representation judicial review labour relations board standard of review union

Bricklayers, Masons Independent Union of Canada, Local 1 v. Prescott Masonry & Restoration Inc.

2019 ONSC 3793 (CanLII) · 2019-06-18

Judicial Review: Labour Relations Union vs Employer

This is a judicial review proceeding concerning a labour relations dispute between a union and an employer. The court addressed procedural motions regarding the admissibility of new evidence to supplement the record and the standard for setting aside a previous order, ultimately dismissing the motions and upholding the lower decision.

employer judicial review labour relations procedure union

Canadian National Railway Company v. Teamsters Canada Rail Conference

2019 ONSC 3644 (CanLII) · 2019-06-13

Judicial Review: Union Affidavit Evidence Admissibility

This is a judicial review proceeding involving a railway company and a union, addressing the admissibility of affidavit evidence in support of the application. The motion judge dismissed the motion to admit affidavits, finding they did not meet the exceptional circumstances required for admission under the Courts of Justice Act.

affidavit evidence civil procedure judicial review labour relations union

O. c. Conseil des écoles publiques de l’Est de l’Ontario

2019 ONCA 460 (CanLII) · 2019-06-04

An appeal in a labour relations matter involving a union and an arbitrator's decision regarding public schools.

arbitration labour relations public schools union

General Motors of Canada Company v. Unifor Canada

2019 ONSC 2627 (CanLII) · 2019-04-26

This is an interlocutory proceeding involving an application for an interim injunction in the context of a labour dispute between an employer and a union. The case addresses procedural matters regarding strikes and industrial action.

injunction labour relations strike union

Audio Visual Services (Canada) Corporation v. Ontario Labour Relations Board

2019 ONSC 1167 (CanLII) · 2019-02-19

Stay of Certification Order Dismissed: Irreparable Harm

This is a judicial review proceeding where an employer sought a stay of an Ontario Labour Relations Board certification order designating a union as the exclusive bargaining agent. The Divisional Court applied the RJR MacDonald test and dismissed the motion for a stay, finding that the employer failed to establish irreparable harm.

certification judicial review labour relations stay of order union

M. v. Ontario Labour Relations Board

2018 ONSC 5959 (CanLII) · 2018-10-09

Appeal: Duty of Fair Representation

This appeal concerned a judicial review application challenging the Ontario Labour Relations Board's decision to dismiss the applicant's claim that his union breached its duty of fair representation. The Divisional Court dismissed the application. The appeal addressed whether the Board's decision regarding the union's handling of grievances and settlement was reasonable and procedurally fair.

duty of fair representation judicial review labour relations board reasonableness union

C. v. Ontario Public Service Employees Union

2018 ONSC 3876 (CanLII) · 2018-06-20

Judicial Review: Union Duty of Fair Representation

An application for judicial review was dismissed regarding the Ontario Public Service Employees Union's alleged breach of its duty of fair representation. The Divisional Court applied the reasonableness standard and found no reviewable error in the Board's findings that the union did not act with bias or bad faith in refusing to seek judicial review of a grievance decision.

duty of fair representation judicial review labour relations standard of review union

M. v Canadian Union of Public Employees, Local 79

2016 ONSC 6745 (CanLII) · 2016-10-27

This judicial review addressed whether the Labour Relations Board reasonably dismissed a duty of fair representation complaint against the union and declined to reconsider its initial decision. The court found no basis to fault the Board's approach, noting the union acted reasonably in abandoning the judicial review to protect the employee's reinstatement, and dismissed the application.

duty of fair representation judicial review labour relations reasonableness union

Canadian Union of Postal Workers v Her Majesty in Right of Canada and Canada Post Corporation

2016 ONSC 1879 (CanLII) · 2016-03-16

A labour relations matter involving the Canadian Union of Postal Workers and Canada Post Corporation concerning collective agreements and bargaining agreements, with a procedural focus on interveners.

collective agreements interveners labour relations union

T.-B. v. Ontario Public Service Employees Union

2015 ONCA 495 (CanLII) · 2015-07-03

Union President Blog Posts: Human Rights Appeal

This is an appeal to the Court of Appeal from a Divisional Court decision on a judicial review concerning whether union blog posts constituted workplace discrimination. The parties were a manager, the union, and the union president who authored blog posts criticizing the manager. The Human Rights Tribunal and Divisional Court found the posts did not violate the Human Rights Code, balancing the manager's right to equal treatment against the union president's freedom of expression and association. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, agreeing that the Tribunal properly balanced the relevant Charter values with the statutory objectives of the Code. The dismissal of the human rights complaint stands.

charter values discrimination doré framework human rights union

EllisDon Corporation v. Ontario Sheet Metal Workers' and Roofers' Conference and International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, Local 586

2015 ONCA 7 (CanLII) · 2015-01-08

Labour Relations: Estoppel Period Clarification

This is an appeal decision by the Court of Appeal for Ontario restoring an Ontario Labour Relations Board ruling in a labour relations matter. The court issued an addendum to clarify the application of the two-year estoppel period following its decision, addressing whether the period restarts from the date of the appellate decision.

collective agreements estoppel period grievance arbitration labour relations union

Ontario Secondary School Teachers’ Federation v. The Brant Haldimand Norfolk Catholic District School Board

2014 ONSC 3260 (CanLII) · 2014-06-03

This is a procedural ruling regarding costs in a labour arbitration dispute between a teachers' federation and a school board.

costs labour arbitration school board union

Ontario Secondary School Teachers’ Federation of Ontario v. The Upper Canada District School Board

2014 ONSC 2346 (CanLII) · 2014-04-23

This is a judicial review or appeal concerning a grievance arbitration award between the Ontario Secondary School Teachers’ Federation and the Upper Canada District School Board. The Divisional Court addressed issues related to the interpretation of collective agreements and the scope of arbitration jurisdiction.

collective agreements grievance arbitration labour relations union

United Food and Commercial Workers Canada, Local 175 v. Olymel, B.

2014 ONSC 1119 (CanLII) · 2014-02-21

A judicial review application brought by a union challenging a decision of a labour or employment tribunal. The Divisional Court reviewed the administrative decision in the context of labour relations.

administrative law judicial review labour relations union