Ontario Severance

Unlawful Strike — Ontario Employment Law

10 casesDecisions from 1954–2007

Have a question about your own situation?

Ask our AI assistant about Ontario employment law.

Ask a question

Free, no account needed

About Unlawful Strike

In Ontario's labour relations regime, the right to strike is highly regulated and restricted to specific timeframes and circumstances. An 'unlawful strike' occurs when employees engage in a work stoppage, slowdown, or other concerted activity designed to restrict output outside of the legally permitted windows set by the Labour Relations Act, 1995 (LRA). By law, strikes are strictly prohibited during the active term of a collective agreement. This is known as the 'peace obligation.' Employees are only in a legal position to strike during collective bargaining after an existing agreement has expired, mandatory conciliation has failed, the Minister of Labour has issued a 'no board' notice, and 16 days have passed after the day it is deemed released (or 9 days after a conciliation board's or mediator's report), as section 79(2) of the LRA requires.

Beyond timing, strikes are inherently unlawful for workers in critical sectors. Under legislation like the Hospital Labour Disputes Arbitration Act (HLDAA) and specific statutes governing police and firefighters, essential workers do not have the right to strike. Disputes in these sectors are instead resolved through binding interest arbitration. When a prohibited work stoppage occurs—such as a 'wildcat strike' where workers walk out without union authorization, or illegal actions by healthcare workers—employers have swift legal remedies available.

In the event of an unlawful strike, employers typically apply on an expedited basis to the Ontario Labour Relations Board (OLRB). The OLRB has the authority to declare the strike unlawful and issue immediate cease-and-desist directions to the union, its officers, and participating employees. In situations involving mass disruption, violence, or defiance of OLRB orders, employers or the Attorney General may escalate the matter to the Superior Court of Justice to seek injunctions or pursue contempt proceedings. Furthermore, any concessions or agreements an employer is forced to sign under the direct threat or execution of an unlawful strike may be deemed unenforceable by the OLRB.

Because the boundaries of concerted workplace action are strictly governed by statutory timelines, technical 'no board' rules, and industry-specific legislation, interpreting whether a slowdown or walkout crosses into illegal territory demands exact legal analysis. Employers facing unexpected work stoppages, or unions navigating worker unrest, should urgently secure specialized legal counsel to understand their strategic rights and liabilities.

Frequently Asked Questions

What legally constitutes an unlawful strike in Ontario?

A strike is unlawful if it occurs while a collective agreement is still in effect, or if the union has not yet exhausted the mandatory conciliation process and the waiting period under the Labour Relations Act (16 days after a "no-board" notice is deemed released, or 9 days after a conciliation board's or mediator's report). It also includes unauthorized 'wildcat' walkouts or orchestrated slowdowns meant to restrict production.

Can hospital workers or police officers go on strike?

No. Under Ontario laws such as the Hospital Labour Disputes Arbitration Act and the Police Services Act, strikes by hospital employees, police officers, and firefighters are strictly prohibited and immediately unlawful. Their contract disputes must be resolved through binding arbitration.

What is a wildcat strike, and is it legal?

A wildcat strike is a spontaneous work stoppage initiated by unionized employees without the authorization or official approval of their union leadership. Because these almost always occur during the term of a valid collective agreement, they are unlawful in Ontario.

Can a concerted work slowdown be considered an unlawful strike?

Yes. Under the Labour Relations Act, a strike is not just a complete walkout. If employees coordinate a deliberate slowdown or 'work-to-rule' campaign specifically designed to restrict output when they are not in a legal strike position, the OLRB can declare it an unlawful strike.

Is an agreement signed to end an unlawful strike legally binding?

Not necessarily. If a union or group of employees extracts a new collective agreement or concessions through the duress of an unlawful strike, the Ontario Labour Relations Board may refuse to enforce those terms, viewing them as the product of illegal coercion.

Can individual employees be sued for participating in an unlawful strike?

Typically, the legal recourse is directed at the union through OLRB declarations or grievance arbitration for corporate damages. However, individual employees engaging in unlawful strikes can be subject to severe workplace discipline, up to and including termination, based on the terms of the collective agreement.

When does an employer need to call a lawyer about an illegal walkout?

An employer should contact a labour lawyer the moment a premature strike or organized slowdown is threatened. Prompt legal intervention is required to rapidly file an application with the OLRB for a cease-and-desist order to minimize business interruption.

Common Scenarios

  • Mid-Contract Walkout: A group of manufacturing employees becomes heavily frustrated with management's new shift scheduling policies and stages a coordinated sick-out, effectively halting production while their collective agreement is still active.
  • Essential Services Defiance: Non-medical support staff at a municipal hospital, upset over stalled wage negotiations, organize a parking lot blockade. Because they fall under the HLDAA, the Attorney General seeks a swift court injunction to stop the unlawful action.
  • Premature Bargaining Dispute: A union calls for a strike directly following a breakdown in bargaining negotiations, but they do so before the Ministry of Labour has officially issued a 'no board' report and before the 16-day waiting period after that notice has passed.
  • Concerted Slowdown: Warehouse workers, attempting to pressure an employer into resolving a string of unresolved grievances, quietly agree among themselves to process only half their usual quota per hour. The employer applies to the OLRB, asserting the coordinated slowdown meets the definition of an unlawful strike.

What You Should Know

  • Act with urgency. If an unlawful strike occurs, immediately begin gathering evidence and contact a labour relations lawyer to file an expedited application to the OLRB for an unlawful strike declaration.
  • Carefully document the disruption. Keep detailed logs of which employees are off the job, the timelines of the walkout, what union leaders are saying, and the exact financial impact on operations.
  • Avoid making panicked concessions. Do not sign binding amendments to a collective agreement in the heat of a wildcat strike without legal advice, as you risk validating unlawful pressure tactics.
  • Remind union leadership of their obligations. The OLRB generally expects union officials to take proactive, demonstrable steps to persuade their members to return to work during an unauthorized 'wildcat' action.
  • Consider the proper venue for remedies. While the OLRB is the primary authority to stop a strike, claiming financial damages caused by the unlawful strike is usually done via a grievance filed against the union and resolved before an arbitrator.

Featured Cases

Amalgamated Transit Union Local 113

2007 CanLII 59152 (ON SCDC) · 2007-10-01

OLRB Judicial Review: Unlawful Strike & Procedural Fairness

This is a judicial review of an Ontario Labour Relations Board decision regarding an alleged unlawful strike by the Amalgamated Transit Union Local 113. The employer sought a cease and desist order, while the union alleged procedural unfairness in the Board's expedited hearing process, including issues of notice and time limits for evidence. The Divisional Court reviewed whether the OLRB acted within its jurisdiction and breached procedural fairness in managing the urgent hearing.

judicial review labour relations olrb procedural fairness unlawful strike

Re International Union of Operating Engineers, Local 793 and Traugott Construction Ltd.

1984 CanLII 2011 (ON SC) · 1984-01-20

Judicial Review: Unlawful Strike Collective Agreement

This is a judicial review proceeding concerning the Ontario Labour Relations Board's refusal to enforce a collective agreement obtained through an unlawful strike. The court examined whether the Board erred in its interpretation of the Labour Relations Act and whether its decision was patently unreasonable, ultimately upholding the Board's refusal to enforce the agreement.

collective agreements enforcement judicial review labour relations unlawful strike

Re Ajax and Pickering General Hospital et al. and Canadian Union of Public Employees et al.

1981 CanLII 1917 (ON SC) · 1981-02-06

Union Contempt: Court Lacks Jurisdiction for Past Strike

This is a procedural ruling concerning the jurisdiction of the court to punish a union for contempt of an Ontario Labour Relations Board direction after the unlawful strike had ceased. The court determined that it lacked jurisdiction to punish for past conduct under the Labour Relations Act and that the statutory powers procedure provided the appropriate alternative remedy.

contempt enforcement jurisdiction labour relations unlawful strike

Attorney-General for Ontario v. Canadian Union of Public Employees

1981 CanLII 1795 (ON SC) · 1981-01-30

Injunction Against Hospital Strikes: Attorney-General Powers

The Attorney-General for Ontario sought an injunction to restrain hospital employees from striking in violation of labour statutes. The court addressed whether the Attorney-General was required to exhaust other remedies before seeking injunctive relief and whether the evidence was sufficient to justify the injunction against specific defendants.

attorney-general hospital employees injunction labour relations unlawful strike

Charterways Transportation Ltd. v. A. et al.

1975 CanLII 444 (ON SC) · 1975-05-13

This is a labour relations case concerning an injunction sought against picketing and an unlawful strike. The dispute arises from the industrial action taken by employees or their union against the employer.

injunction labour relations picketing unlawful strike

Amoco Canada Petroleum Co. Ltd. v. H. et al.

1974 CanLII 532 (ON SC) · 1974-05-17

Illegal Strike Injunction: Labour Relations Act Enforcement

A labour and employment case involving an illegal strike and the enforcement of an injunction to prohibit picketing. The court ruled that all picketing, including peaceful picketing, may be enjoined if it causes substantial or irreparable harm to the employer, under the Labour Relations Act.

injunction labour and employment labour relations act picketing unlawful strike

D. et al. v. D. et al.

1957 CanLII 809 (ON SC) · 1957-03-11

Employment Interference Case: Conspiracy and Unlawful Strike Claims Dismissed

A case involving allegations of conspiracy and interference with employment, where plaintiffs claimed defendants conspired to prevent their employment or procure their discharge through threats of an unlawful strike. The court found that the agreement among union members to refuse work alongside non-affiliated members was lawful, and the threat of an unlawful strike was insufficient to establish actionable interference without intent to injure.

breach of contract conspiracy employment interference intent to injure unlawful strike

Smith Bros. Construction Co. Limited v. J. et al.

1955 CanLII 152 (ON SC) · 1955-03-14

Union Picketing and Unlawful Strike Injunction

This is a civil action involving tortious interference with contractual relations arising from union picketing activities. The court examined whether union officers' actions constituted an unlawful strike under the Labour Relations Act and whether they unjustifiably induced third parties to cease work. A permanent injunction was granted against the union officers to prevent further interference.

injunction labour relations picketing tortious interference unlawful strike

D. v. T., K., L. and M.

1954 CanLII 346 (ON SC) · 1954-08-25

Unlawful Strike: Injunction Against Union Officers

This is an interlocutory proceeding where an injunction was granted to restrain union officers from picketing and interfering with the plaintiff's business during an unlawful strike. The court addressed whether the illegality of the strike affected the common law right to picket and found that active participation by union officers constituted unlawful encouragement of the illegal strike under the Labour Relations Act.

labour relations picketing union officers unlawful strike

Smith Bros. Construction Co. Ltd. v. J. et al.

1954 CanLII 348 (ON SC) · 1954-02-12

Unlawful Strike Injunction: Picketing & Contractual Interference

This is an interlocutory proceeding seeking an interim injunction to restrain unlawful strike activity and picketing by a union. The court considered whether the defendants' actions, including threats of contractual breaches, violated the Ontario Labour Relations Act and constituted wrongful interference with third-party contracts, relying on findings by the Ontario Labour Relations Board.

injunctive relief labour relations picketing unlawful strike