Ontario Severance

Vaccination Policy — Ontario Employment Law

8 casesDecisions from 2022–2025

Have a question about your own situation?

Ask our AI assistant about Ontario employment law.

Ask a question

Free, no account needed

About Vaccination Policy

Workplace vaccination policies became one of the most heavily debated areas of Ontario employment law during the COVID-19 pandemic. While the initial wave of pandemic-related mandates has largely passed, the legal decisions from that era created crucial precedents for how employers can enforce health and safety rules, and what happens to workers who refuse to comply. In Ontario, employers have a general duty under the Occupational Health and Safety Act (OHSA) to take reasonable precautions to protect workers. To meet this duty, many companies implemented mandatory vaccination policies.

The most pressing legal question remains: Can an employer fire you for refusing to follow a vaccination policy? In most non-unionized workplaces, an employer can terminate an employee at any time for almost any reason, provided it is not discriminatory. Therefore, an employer generally has the right to let you go if you remain unvaccinated. However, the real dispute in these cases is over severance pay. Employers frequently tried to argue that refusing a vaccine constituted "just cause" or "wilful misconduct" under the Employment Standards Act (ESA), which would strip the employee of their right to notice or severance. Ontario courts have largely rejected this approach for non-unionized workers. Unless the policy was mandated by law or absolutely essential to the job, judges have frequently ruled that firing an employee for non-compliance is a wrongful dismissal without cause, meaning full severance is still owed.

Another major legal argument employers use is "frustration of contract." If an employer's primary client or a government regulation makes it legally impossible for an unvaccinated person to perform their duties, an employer might claim the employment contract has been frustrated through no fault of their own.

Navigating these competing obligations involves looking closely at the timing of the policy, the specific wording of your employment contract, and the nature of your industry, which means having a qualified legal professional assess your specific circumstances is essential.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I be fired for refusing a mandatory workplace vaccine?

Yes. Generally, a non-unionized employer in Ontario can terminate your employment for refusing to abide by a vaccination policy. However, unless they can prove "just cause," they are legally required to provide you with adequate notice or severance pay in lieu of notice.

Does refusing a vaccine mean I lose my right to severance pay?

Usually, no. Ontario courts have found that breaching a company-created vaccination policy rarely meets the high standard of "wilful misconduct" required to deny your minimum entitlements under the ESA, meaning you are likely still owed severance.

Can I claim a human rights exemption from a vaccine mandate?

Under the Ontario Human Rights Code, you can request accommodation if you cannot be vaccinated due to a protected ground, such as a documented medical disability or a recognized religious belief. Personal, political, or ethical objections to vaccines do not qualify for human rights protection.

What happens if I am placed on an unpaid leave for being unvaccinated?

Being forced onto an indefinite unpaid leave of absence because of your vaccination status may amount to a constructive dismissal. This depends on whether your employment contract gave the employer the right to suspend you without pay.

How does frustration of contract apply to vaccination policies?

If an unforeseen event—such as a government mandate or an absolute requirement from the employer's only client—makes it impossible for you to work while unvaccinated, the employer might argue the contract is frustrated. If successful, this can end the employment relationship without common law severance.

When should I have a lawyer review my vaccine-related termination?

If you are fired and your employer claims they have "just cause" to deny your severance because you did not follow a health mandate, you should immediately have a lawyer evaluate whether their policy actually justifies a zero-compensation dismissal.

Common Scenarios

  • An office administrator declines to get a newly mandated booster shot, and the employer fires them for "just cause," refusing to pay any severance despite the absence of any government mandate requiring the booster.
  • A security guard is banned from a major worksite because the site's owner strictly requires all contractors to be vaccinated, leading the security firm to argue the guard's employment contract is now legally frustrated.
  • An employee with a history of severe allergic reactions provides a doctor's note explicitly advising against a specific vaccination, but the employer refuses to accommodate them and issues a termination notice instead.
  • A retail worker is placed on a continuous, unpaid leave of absence for failing to upload proof of vaccination to the company portal, severely impacting their income and prompting a claim for constructive dismissal.

What You Should Know

  • Always secure a copy of the exact vaccination policy, including the date it was implemented and any consequences clearly outlined for non-compliance.
  • If you are seeking a medical or religious exemption, provide your employer with clear, written documentation from a physician or religious leader as early as possible to trigger their duty to accommodate.
  • Do not assume that an employer's claim of "wilful misconduct" will hold up in court; the threshold to completely deny ESA minimums is exceptionally high.
  • Because rulings on workplace mandates depend heavily on whether a third party required the policy, it is highly recommended to seek skilled legal input before formally refusing a directive and risking your job.

Featured Cases

P. v. Sensient Colors

2025 ONSC 3127 (CanLII) · 2025-05-26

Wrongful Dismissal: 12 Months Notice for Vaccination Refusal

This wrongful dismissal case involved an employee terminated for refusing to comply with the employer's mandatory COVID-19 vaccination policy. The court found that the employer failed to establish just cause for termination and applied the Bardal factors to determine a reasonable notice period. The employee was awarded 12 months' notice and damages totaling $182,822.84, with the court rejecting the employer's arguments regarding wilful misconduct, frustration of contract, and failure to mitigate damages.

damages just cause reasonable notice vaccination policy wrongful dismissal

Humber River Health v. Teamsters Local Union No. 419

2025 ONSC 2270 (CanLII) · 2025-05-06

Judicial Review: Mandatory Vaccination Policy Arbitration

This is a judicial review of a labour arbitration decision concerning an employer's mandatory COVID-19 vaccination policy and the termination of employees for non-compliance. The Divisional Court examined whether the arbitrator unreasonably concluded that non-compliance could never justify discipline and failed to properly balance the employer's health and safety obligations with employees' privacy and medical consent rights.

health and safety judicial review labour arbitration termination vaccination policy

C. v. VuPoint System Ltd.

2024 ONCA 354 (CanLII) · 2024-05-07

Appeal dismissed: Contract frustrated by vaccine policy

This is an appeal to the Court of Appeal from a motion judge's decision dismissing a wrongful dismissal action over a mandatory COVID-19 vaccination policy. The employee, a technician, sued his employer after being terminated for refusing to comply with a vaccine mandate imposed by the employer's dominant client. The motion judge dismissed the action, finding that the employment contract was frustrated by the client's policy. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, holding that the third-party policy was an unforeseeable supervening event that radically altered the employment obligations by rendering the employee ineligible to work. As a result, the finding of frustration stands and the employee is awarded no damages.

appeal employment contract frustration of contract vaccination policy wrongful dismissal

M. v. Bayer Inc.

2023 ONSC 4875 (CanLII) · 2023-08-25

Wrongful Dismissal: Discovery Relevance on Vaccination Status

This is an interlocutory motion concerning discovery in a wrongful dismissal action where the plaintiff was terminated for non-compliance with a COVID-19 vaccination policy. The defendant sought answers to refused discovery questions regarding the plaintiff's vaccination status and research to address issues of mitigation of damages and reasonableness of conduct. The court applied the principle that relevance in discovery is determined by the pleadings rather than admissibility at trial, ultimately awarding the defendant reduced costs of $2,000.

costs discovery relevance vaccination policy wrongful dismissal

C. v. VuPoint Systems Ltd.

2023 ONSC 1234 (CanLII) · 2023-02-21

Frustration of Contract: Vaccination Policy Termination

The plaintiff's employment was terminated after they refused to comply with a mandatory COVID-19 vaccination policy required by the employer's primary client. The court found that the employment contract was frustrated due to the employee's inability to perform their duties. As a result, the court granted summary judgment and ruled the employee was not entitled to damages for wrongful dismissal.

frustration of contract summary judgment termination vaccination policy wrongful dismissal

National Organized Workers Union v. Sinai Health System

2022 ONCA 802 (CanLII) · 2022-11-22

Union Injunction: Mandatory Vaccination Policy

This is an appeal to the Court of Appeal from an application judge's decision denying an interlocutory injunction. The union sought to prevent the hospital employer from enforcing a mandatory COVID-19 vaccination policy pending grievance arbitration. The application judge declined to intervene, finding that the potential harm of lost income could be fully remedied by an arbitrator. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, confirming there was no remedial gap in the labour relations process to justify the court's residual jurisdiction. The denial of the injunction stands.

grievance arbitration injunctive relief labour relations residual jurisdiction vaccination policy

B. v City of Hamilton

2022 ONSC 5977 (CanLII) · 2022-10-21

Mootness: Hamilton Vaccination Policy Challenge Dismissed

This is a procedural ruling where the court dismissed an application challenging the City of Hamilton's mandatory COVID-19 vaccination policy and its termination provisions. The court found the application moot because the termination provisions had been suspended, meaning there was no longer a live controversy to adjudicate.

civil procedure mootness termination vaccination policy workplace discrimination

K. v. C.

2022 ONSC 3986 (CanLII) · 2022-07-05

K. v. C.: Corporate Officer Liability & Wrongful Dismissal

This is an interlocutory proceeding involving a motion to strike pleadings in a case where the claimant sued a corporate officer personally for alleged breaches of employment terms and constructive dismissal due to a mandatory vaccination policy. The court addressed whether corporate officers can be held personally liable for employment contract breaches and whether pseudo-legal arguments should be accepted. The claimant was advised to amend her claim to sue the employer directly for wrongful dismissal.

constructive dismissal corporate officer liability employment contract vaccination policy wrongful dismissal