Ontario (Labour) v. Sudbury (City)
OHSA Employer Liability: City of Sudbury Appeal
Summary
This appeal concerns the liability of the City of Sudbury as an employer under the Occupational Health and Safety Act for breaches of safety regulations. The Court of Appeal addressed whether the municipality assumed employer responsibilities by employing inspectors at a project site and whether the due diligence defence should be remitted for further consideration. This decision was appealed to the Supreme Court of Canada, which upheld it (R. v. Greater Sudbury (City), 2023 SCC 28). The Supreme Court of Canada dismissed the appeal on equal division, meaning the Court of Appeal's decision stands. The City is considered an employer under the Act and the matter of its due diligence defence is remitted to the provincial offences appeal court.
Have a question about your own situation?
Ask our AI assistant about Ontario employment law.
Free, no account needed
Outcome
appeal allowed; matter remitted to the appeal court; upheld by the Supreme Court of Canada (2023 SCC 28)
Key Factors
- Occupational Health and Safety Act
- Employer liability
- Due diligence defence
- Statutory interpretation
- Municipal employer status
Related Cases
Ontario (Ministry of Labour, Immigration, Training and Skills Development) v. Greater Sudbury (City)
2026 ONSC 3671 (CanLII) · 2026-07-10OHSA Appeal: Due Diligence and Standard of Review
An appeal of convictions under the Occupational Health and Safety Act against the City of Sudbury for alleged failures to ensure workplace safety. The court addressed the standard of review for OHSA prosecutions, finding that questions of law are reviewed on a correctness standard while mixed questions of fact and law are reviewed for palpable and overriding error. The appeal was allowed and acquittals entered because the trial judge's findings were unsupported by evidence and based on speculation.
L. v. K.
2026 ONSC 3804 (CanLII) · 2026-07-02This is a judicial review application concerning the Workplace Safety and Insurance Appeals Tribunal's (WSIAT) decisions on workers' compensation matters. The applicant challenged the tribunal's procedural fairness in separating Charter and Human Rights Code issues, its jurisdiction to defer entitlements pending WSIB review, the use of medical discussion papers, and allegations of bias. The Divisional Court found the tribunal's processes reasonable, fair, and consistent with the WSIA.
S. v. Queen’s University
2026 ONSC 2253 (CanLII) · 2026-04-22Workplace Investigation Independence: OHS Act Injunction Refused
This is an interlocutory proceeding concerning an application for interim relief and a mandatory order related to an investigation under the Occupational Health and Safety Act. The court applied the RJR-MacDonald test to determine whether to grant an injunction or mandatory order to compel or restrain an investigation, ultimately refusing relief as the balance of convenience favored the statutory duty to investigate and irreparable harm was speculative.
K. v. Workplace Safety and Insurance Appeals Tribunal
2026 ONSC 2192 (CanLII) · 2026-04-16Judicial Review of WSIAT Decision on Workplace Injury
This is a judicial review application concerning the reasonableness of the WSIAT's decision on a worker's entitlement to compensation for workplace injuries. The Divisional Court reviewed the Tribunal's assessment of medical evidence and its refusal to grant reconsideration.
D. v. B.
2025 ONSC 7075 (CanLII) · 2025-12-19Police Officer Tort Claim vs Discipline Proceedings
This is a procedural ruling on a motion to strike where the plaintiff, a police officer, sought to pursue tort claims linked to internal police discipline proceedings. The court determined it had residual jurisdiction because the dispute had moved beyond the collective agreement into the criminal justice system, and rejected arguments that statutory privilege barred the civil claims.
More Ontario employment decisions from 2021
This summary was written by AI from the published decision and its headnote. It is not an official version of the decision; read the full text on CanLII before relying on it. This is legal information, not legal advice. Ontario Severance is an educational tool. If you are facing a serious employment law matter, consult with a qualified employment lawyer in Ontario.