Ontario Severance

Due Diligence — Ontario Employment Law

25 casesDecisions from 1986–2026

Have a question about your own situation?

Ask our AI assistant about Ontario employment law.

Ask a question

Free, no account needed

About Due Diligence

In the realm of Ontario employment and regulatory law, 'due diligence' is much more than a corporate buzzword—it is a critical legal defence mechanism. Under the Occupational Health and Safety Act (OHSA), most workplace safety violations are categorized as 'strict liability' offences. This means that if an accident happens or a safety standard is breached, the Crown does not need to prove that the employer intentionally or recklessly broke the rules. The mere fact that the prohibited event occurred is enough to lay charges. However, a defendant can avoid conviction if they can prove the defence of due diligence.

To establish due diligence, an employer, supervisor, or director must demonstrate on a balance of probabilities that they took 'every precaution reasonable in the circumstances' to prevent the incident. Proving this requires showing a proactive, robust, and functional system of compliance. It is not enough to simply have a safety manual sitting on a shelf. Ontario courts look for a living, breathing health and safety culture. This involves identifying foreseeable workplace hazards, developing specific protocols to mitigate those risks, actively training staff on these protocols, and strictly enforcing compliance through monitoring and progressive discipline.

A significant element of due diligence involves addressing the 'human factor.' If a worker violates a safety rule—such as removing a machine guard or failing to wear a harness—the employer might still be held liable unless they can show they actively supervised the worker and historically enforced the rules. Allowing minor safety infractions to slide routinely destroys a due diligence defence when a major accident eventually occurs.

Because workplace risks vary wildly between a manufacturing plant, a corporate office, and a municipal construction site, the standard for what is 'reasonable' is constantly shifting based on industry norms and specific site conditions. Figuring out whether your current safety protocols meet the legal threshold requires a deep understanding of regulatory expectations. Consequently, seeking out tailored advice from a legal professional knowledgeable in Ontario occupational health and safety law is an essential step before a Ministry of Labour inspector ever knocks on your door.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does it mean to prove due diligence under the OHSA?

Proving due diligence means demonstrating that you took every reasonable precaution to prevent a workplace health and safety offence from happening. The burden rests on the employer or supervisor to provide documented evidence of hazard assessments, safety policies, worker training, and consistent rule enforcement.

Is having a customized written safety manual enough to avoid liability?

No, a written manual is only the first step. Ontario courts frequently reject the due diligence defence if the employer had strong policies on paper but failed to adequately train employees on them, or neglected to supervise and discipline workers who ignored the rules.

Can supervisors and managers be personally charged if they fail to show due diligence?

Yes. Under Ontario's OHSA, individual supervisors and corporate directors have specific legal duties to ensure worker safety. If an incident occurs and they cannot prove they personally took reasonable steps to enforce safety requirements, they can face personal fines or even jail time.

Are there deadlines for the Ministry of Labour to lay strict liability charges?

Yes. Under section 69 of the OHSA, charges must generally be laid within one year of the date the offence occurred, or within one year of the date an inspector became aware of the alleged offence. Preserving your due diligence evidence immediately after an incident is vital during this limitation period.

How do courts decide if my company's precautions were 'reasonable' in the circumstances?

Courts evaluate reasonableness based on a variety of factors, including the gravity of the potential harm, the foreseeability of the hazard, and the accepted standards within your specific industry. They will analyze what an average, prudent employer in your sector would have done in the same situation.

When is the right time to speak with a regulatory employment lawyer about compliance?

Ideally, it is best to consult legal counsel proactively to audit your current safety systems and ensure they meet the legal standard for a due diligence defence before an incident occurs. However, if a serious workplace accident has just taken place, speaking to a lawyer immediately is critical to protect your rights during the subsequent Ministry investigation.

Common Scenarios

  • An experienced machine operator decides to bypass a mechanical safety guard to speed up production and suffers a serious hand injury. The Ministry of Labour charges the employer, who responds by presenting training logs, routine machine inspection records, and past disciplinary letters given to other employees for similar behaviour, successfully arguing they met their due diligence obligations.
  • A municipality hires a general contractor to repave a busy road, but a fatal pedestrian accident occurs on the site, leading to OHSA charges against the city as a 'constructor'. The city attempts to mount a due diligence defence by showing they thoroughly vetted the contractor's safety record during the bidding process and conducted regular spot-checks of the site.
  • An employee trips over an empty wooden skid left abruptly in a narrow warehouse aisle, sustaining a concussion. The floor supervisor faces personal regulatory charges and must attempt to prove due diligence by demonstrating a consistent routine of aisle inspections and enforcing a clear policy regarding the immediate removal of obstructions.

What You Should Know

  • Maintain meticulous, date-stamped records of all safety meetings, toolbox talks, and hazard assessments, as a 'paper trail' is the most powerful evidence you can present to establish due diligence.
  • Do not turn a blind eye to veteran employees skipping safety steps; consistent and documented disciplinary action for safety violations is crucial to proving you actively enforce your policies.
  • If the Ministry of Labour investigates an incident, cooperate professionally but avoid openly speculating about the cause; rely on your established safety documentation and conduct your own internal investigation.
  • Regularly review and update your workplace safety protocols with an Ontario employment lawyer or OHS consultant, as legal standards for 'reasonable precautions' evolve continuously with new technology and industry practices.

Featured Cases

Ontario (Ministry of Labour, Immigration, Training and Skills Development) v. Greater Sudbury (City)

2026 ONSC 3671 (CanLII) · 2026-07-10

OHSA Appeal: Due Diligence and Standard of Review

An appeal of convictions under the Occupational Health and Safety Act against the City of Sudbury for alleged failures to ensure workplace safety. The court addressed the standard of review for OHSA prosecutions, finding that questions of law are reviewed on a correctness standard while mixed questions of fact and law are reviewed for palpable and overriding error. The appeal was allowed and acquittals entered because the trial judge's findings were unsupported by evidence and based on speculation.

due diligence employer obligations occupational health and safety regulatory offence standard of review

Ontario (Ministry of Labour, Immigration, Training and Skills Development) v. Corporation of the Town of Bancroft

2025 ONCJ 745 (CanLII) · 2025-09-08

OHSA Prosecution: Charge Dismissed for Inaccessible Area

This is a merits decision in a prosecution under the Occupational Health and Safety Act concerning whether an area along rails and under a compactor constituted a 'floor or other surface used by a worker.' The court dismissed the charge, finding that the space was inaccessible and did not present a slip and fall hazard, meaning the actus reus was not proven. The court also found that due diligence was established in the alternative.

due diligence occupational health and safety regulatory prosecutions statutory interpretation workplace safety

Ontario (Labour, Immigration, Training and Skills Development) v. Greater Sudbury (City)

2025 ONCA 329 (CanLII) · 2025-03-31

OHSA Due Diligence Defence: City of Greater Sudbury Appeal

This is an appeal regarding a criminal or statutory infraction under the Occupational Health and Safety Act. The Court of Appeal denied leave to appeal a decision that upheld the City of Greater Sudbury's acquittal for OHSA violations, finding that the lower courts correctly applied the due diligence defence.

appeal due diligence employer liability occupational health and safety statutory infraction

Ontario (Ministry of Labour, Immigration, Training and Skills Development) v. A & L Hammer Workforce Management Inc.

2024 ONCJ 192 (CanLII) · 2024-04-18

A regulatory prosecution of a corporation and its director for 18 counts of failing to comply with orders to pay wages and recruitment fees under the Employment Standards Act and the Employment Protection for Foreign Nationals Act. The court addressed whether the defendants failed to comply with orders, the applicability of the due diligence defence, and whether evidence established that the corporation continued operations despite claims of business closure.

compliance orders due diligence employment standards foreign nationals regulatory prosecutions

Ontario (Labour) v. Bondfield Construction Company Limited

2023 ONCA 813 (CanLII) · 2023-12-05

OHS Appeal: Bondfield Construction Due Diligence

This is an appeal from a decision in a prosecution under the Occupational Health and Safety Act involving Bondfield Construction Company Limited. The Court of Appeal dismissed the leave to appeal, finding that the issues concerned the application of well-established legal principles regarding due diligence and sentencing rather than matters of general importance requiring appellate guidance.

due diligence leave to appeal occupational health and safety regulatory offence sentencing

Ontario (Ministry of Labour, Immigration, Training and Skills Development) v. Limen Group Const. (2019) Ltd.

2023 ONCJ 535 (CanLII) · 2023-11-29

OHSA Prosecution: Due Diligence and Employer Liability

This is a merits decision in a statutory prosecution under the Occupational Health and Safety Act involving a corporate defendant and individual supervisors. The court addressed whether the defendants were employers or supervisors, whether they proved due diligence regarding hazardous rigging practices using embedded rebar, and the scope of their duties under the Act. The court found the essential elements of the counts proved and rejected the due diligence defence.

due diligence employer liability occupational health and safety regulatory prosecutions workplace safety

R. v. Bondfield Construction Company Limited

2022 ONCA 302 (CanLII) · 2022-04-14

Court of Appeal Reinstates OHSA Electrical Charges

This is an appeal to the Court of Appeal from an appeal judge's decision regarding employer convictions under the Occupational Health and Safety Act. The Crown appealed the acquittals of three construction and electrical companies after a field service technician was severely burned by an electrical arc flash. The trial justice initially convicted the employers, but the appeal judge overturned the convictions after finding the energized electrical parts were not exposed. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal in part, finding that the appeal judge erred by ignoring the context and purpose of the safety regulations when interpreting the requirement to disconnect power to equipment. The court set aside the acquittals for the power disconnection offences, upheld the acquittals regarding unauthorized room access, and remitted the remaining due diligence and sentencing issues to the lower court.

due diligence electrical hazards occupational health and safety regulatory prosecutions workplace safety

Ontario (Labour) v. Sudbury (City)

2021 ONCA 252 (CanLII) · 2021-04-23

OHSA Employer Liability: City of Sudbury Appeal

This appeal concerns the liability of the City of Sudbury as an employer under the Occupational Health and Safety Act for breaches of safety regulations. The Court of Appeal addressed whether the municipality assumed employer responsibilities by employing inspectors at a project site and whether the due diligence defence should be remitted for further consideration. This decision was appealed to the Supreme Court of Canada, which upheld it (R. v. Greater Sudbury (City), 2023 SCC 28). The Supreme Court of Canada dismissed the appeal on equal division, meaning the Court of Appeal's decision stands. The City is considered an employer under the Act and the matter of its due diligence defence is remitted to the provincial offences appeal court.

due diligence employer liability municipal employer occupational health and safety statutory interpretation

Ontario (Labour) v. Sudbury (City)

2019 ONCA 854 (CanLII) · 2019-10-28

OHSA Employer Liability: Municipality & Due Diligence Appeal

This is a motion to the Court of Appeal for leave to appeal an acquittal under the Occupational Health and Safety Act. The Ministry of Labour charged the City of Greater Sudbury over a fatal construction accident, but the courts below acquitted the municipality after finding it was not an employer because it lacked control over the project. The Court of Appeal granted the motion for leave to appeal because the interpretation of an employer in municipal infrastructure projects raises an important question of law. Leave to appeal the acquittals was granted. The case later reached the Supreme Court of Canada (R. v. Greater Sudbury (City), 2023 SCC 28). The Supreme Court of Canada dismissed the appeal on equal division, meaning the Court of Appeal's decision stands. The City is considered an employer under the Act and the matter of its due diligence defence is remitted to the provincial offences appeal court.

due diligence employer liability municipal liability occupational health and safety statutory interpretation

R. v. Greater Sudbury (City)

2019 ONSC 3285 (CanLII) · 2019-06-06

OHSA Constructor Liability: City of Greater Sudbury

An appellate review of a criminal prosecution under the Occupational Health and Safety Act where the City of Greater Sudbury was charged following a fatal accident at a construction site. The central legal issues were whether the City exercised sufficient control to be deemed a 'constructor' or 'employer' and whether it established a due diligence defence against strict liability offences. The case later reached the Supreme Court of Canada (R. v. Greater Sudbury (City), 2023 SCC 28). The Supreme Court of Canada dismissed the appeal on equal division, meaning the Court of Appeal's decision stands. The City is considered an employer under the Act and the matter of its due diligence defence is remitted to the provincial offences appeal court.

constructor due diligence employer ohsa workplace safety

Ontario (Ministry of the Environment and Climate Change) v. Sunrise Propane Energy Group Inc.

2018 ONCA 461 (CanLII) · 2018-05-15

Workplace Safety Appeal: Due Diligence Defence

This is a motion for leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal from an appeal judge's decision concerning convictions for environmental and workplace safety offences. Sunrise Propane Energy Group Inc. and its directors sought leave to appeal their convictions following a fatal workplace explosion. The trial judge convicted the applicants and imposed fines totalling $5.3 million, which the appeal judge upheld. The Court of Appeal refused leave to appeal because the applicants raised questions of mixed fact and law rather than pure questions of law essential in the public interest. The fines totalling $5.3 million stand.

due diligence occupational health and safety provincial offences regulatory prosecutions workplace safety

R. v. Sunrise Propane Energy Group Inc.

2017 ONSC 6954 (CanLII) · 2017-11-27

Workplace Safety: OHSA Sentencing Appeal

An appeal against sentencing for an employer convicted of strict liability offences under the Occupational Health and Safety Act and Environmental Protection Act following a propane facility explosion that caused death and environmental damage. The court addressed the employer's failure to provide adequate instruction and supervision to employees, the rejection of due diligence and official error defences, and the appropriateness of the fines imposed given the aggravating factors.

due diligence employer liability ohsa sentencing workplace safety

R. v. Wal-Mart Canada Corp.

2017 ONSC 6726 (CanLII) · 2017-11-08

Workplace Safety: Hazard in Aisle

This is an appeal regarding a strict liability offence under the Occupational Health and Safety Act where an employee tripped on an empty skid in a workplace aisle. The court addressed whether the placement of the skid constituted a 'hazard or obstruction' under section 11 of Regulation 851 and whether the employer exercised due diligence. The trial judge's interpretation of the legislation was upheld on appeal.

due diligence employer liability hazard occupational health and safety workplace safety

R. v. Tembec Inc

2013 ONSC 4278 (CanLII) · 2013-06-24

A criminal or statutory infraction proceeding involving an employer charged with offences under occupational health and safety legislation. The case addresses the burden of proof and the defence of due diligence in the context of workplace safety compliance.

burden of proof due diligence occupational health and safety provincial offences

Ontario (Labour) v. Black & Mcdonald Limited

2009 CanLII 39996 (ON SC) · 2009-07-29

OHSA Prosecution: Due Diligence and Sentencing Appeal

This is an appeal regarding the sentencing and procedural handling of charges under the Occupational Health and Safety Act. The court addressed whether the trial judge erred by imposing absolute liability, considering contributory negligence in sentencing, and dismissing counts for vagueness, ultimately dismissing the Ministry of Labour's appeal.

due diligence employer obligations occupational health and safety sentencing workplace safety

R. v. 733515 Ontario Inc. (Triad Exterior Contracting Specialists)

2009 ONCA 29 (CanLII) · 2009-01-14

Workplace Safety: Due Diligence Appeal Dismissed

This is an appeal by a private corporation against a conviction for workplace health and safety infractions. The Court of Appeal for Ontario addressed whether the appellant discharged its due diligence obligation and whether the sentencing decision contained legal error, ultimately finding no error in the lower court's assessment of evidence or imposition of sentence.

criminal conviction due diligence sentencing workplace health and safety

R. v. Dofasco Inc.

2007 ONCA 769 (CanLII) · 2007-11-09

R. v. Dofasco: Employer Liability for Machine Guarding

This was an appeal to the Court of Appeal from a judge's decision affirming an employer's acquittal for workplace safety violations. The Ministry of Labour appealed the acquittal of Dofasco Inc. after a worker was injured on a steel mill lacking a physical guard. The lower courts decided that the employer's alternate safety procedures and the worker's deliberate failure to follow them meant a physical guard was unnecessary. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and entered a conviction, ruling that safety procedures cannot replace a physical guard and that worker misconduct is no defence. The matter was remitted to the justice of the peace for sentencing.

due diligence employer obligations machine guarding strict liability workplace health and safety

Stelco Inc. v. Ontario (Ministry of Labour)

2006 CanLII 28110 (ON SC) · 2006-08-15

Stelco v. Ontario: OHSA Machinery Guarding & Due Diligence

This is an appeal concerning a workplace health and safety prosecution where the employer was fined for inadequate guarding of machinery. The court addressed the adequacy of guarding under Regulation 851, the availability of the due diligence defence, and the defence of officially induced error. The appeal also considered whether a $250,000 fine was excessive given the employer's insolvency under the CCAA.

corporate fine due diligence occupational health and safety strict liability workplace safety

Ontario (Ministry of Labour) v. Pioneer Construction Inc.

2006 CanLII 15621 (ON CA) · 2006-05-12

OHS Appeal: Employer Definition & Due Diligence

This is an appeal from a conviction under the Occupational Health and Safety Act involving a construction company. The Court of Appeal upheld the conviction, confirming that the defendant qualified as an 'employer' under the Act and that the trial judge correctly rejected the due diligence defence regarding the failure to guard machinery and provide supervision. The court also dismissed the corporate defendant's Charter argument regarding delay, ruling that the presumption of prejudice does not apply to corporations.

charter rights due diligence employer definition occupational health and safety workplace safety

R. v. Canada Brick Ltd.

2005 CanLII 24925 (ON SC) · 2005-06-30

Workplace Safety: Due Diligence and Charter Breach

This is a criminal prosecution of an employer under the Occupational Health and Safety Act for failing to implement reasonable precautions to protect workers from injury by unguarded machinery. The case addresses the due diligence defence, the objective standard of foreseeability for workplace hazards, and a Charter challenge regarding warrantless inspections by Ministry of Labour inspectors.

charter rights due diligence occupational health and safety regulatory offence workplace safety