Employee Duties — Ontario Employment Law
Have a question about your own situation?
Ask our AI assistant about Ontario employment law.
Free, no account needed
Related Keywords
About Employee Duties
When entering an employment relationship in Ontario, much of the focus is typically on what the employer must provide, such as wages under the Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA) or a safe workspace under the Occupational Health and Safety Act (OHSA). However, the employment contract is a two-way street. Under Ontario common law, employees also owe fundamental legal duties to their employers. Understanding these obligations is crucial for maintaining a healthy workplace and avoiding severe legal consequences, including termination for cause or civil liability.
An employee's duties generally fall into two categories: express and implied. Express duties are those written directly into an employment contract, such as specific job responsibilities, working hours, or policies regarding outside employment. Implied duties, on the other hand, apply to almost every employee in Ontario by default, even if there is no written contract. The most universal implied duty is the duty of good faith and fidelity. This requires an employee to act honestly, serve the employer's interests faithfully during working hours, and avoid glaring conflicts of interest.
Employees also owe a duty of competence and care, meaning they must perform their work to a reasonable standard, and a duty of obedience, which requires them to follow the lawful and safe directions of management. It is important to note that the duty of obedience does not override statutory rights; under the OHSA, for instance, employees have the legal right—and duty—to refuse unsafe work without being deemed insubordinate.
Additionally, all employees owe a duty of confidentiality regarding their employer's proprietary and trade information. While basic employees owe these standard duties, senior executives, directors, or key managerial staff may be classified as "fiduciaries." Fiduciary employees owe a significantly higher duty of loyalty, meaning they must put the employer's interests ahead of their own and face strict limitations on competing or soliciting clients post-employment. Because the line between standard employee duties and strict fiduciary obligations is heavily dependent on specific job tasks and workplace dynamics, seeking guidance from an employment law professional is the most reliable way to understand how these legal principles map onto your unique situation.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the basic implied duties every employee owes to their employer in Ontario?
Under Ontario common law, every employee implicitly owes their employer basic duties even without a written contract. These include the duty of good faith and fidelity (acting honestly), the duty of competence (performing the job reasonably well), the duty of obedience (following lawful, safe instructions), and the duty of confidentiality.
Can I be fired for cause if I refuse to follow my manager's direct orders?
Refusing a lawful and reasonable direction is generally considered insubordination, which breaches your duty of obedience and can lead to discipline or termination for cause. However, if the order requires you to perform an illegal act or puts your safety at risk, you are protected under laws like the Occupational Health and Safety Act when you refuse.
Am I allowed to work a second job while employed full-time?
This depends on your primary employer's policies and your implied duty of fidelity. Working a second job is often permissible unless it creates a conflict of interest, impacts your performance at your primary job, or if your employment contract contains an express "exclusive service" clause prohibiting outside work.
Do my legal obligations to my employer end completely on the day I quit?
No. While your daily duties to perform work cease, your duty of confidentiality survives the end of your employment. You cannot take or use your former employer's trade secrets or confidential client lists, and if you are a fiduciary or bound by restrictive covenants, you may have additional post-employment restrictions.
When should I consult an employment lawyer about my workplace obligations?
You should seek legal counsel immediately if your employer accuses you of breaching your duties, such as alleging a conflict of interest, or if they threaten legal action regarding confidentiality. It is also wise to consult a lawyer before starting a side business that might compete with your current employer.
What is the difference between a regular employee's duty and a fiduciary duty?
A regular employee must act in good faith and avoid harming the employer's interests, but they can generally plan to compete once they leave. A fiduciary employee (usually a senior executive or key manager) owes a stricter duty of absolute loyalty, requiring them to put the company's interests above their own and strictly limiting post-employment competition.
Common Scenarios
- A mid-level software developer at a tech firm begins using the company's proprietary code to build an app for a personal side business, directly breaching their implied duty of fidelity and duty of confidentiality.
- A warehouse worker refuses to operate a forklift because the brakes are malfunctioning. The employer attempts to discipline them for breaching their duty of obedience, but the worker is protected by their statutory right to refuse unsafe work under the OHSA.
- A departing sales representative discreetly emails a master list of the company's top clients to their personal email address on their last day, intending to use it at a competing firm, which violates their legal duty to protect company property.
- A senior vice president plans to resign and aggressively recruits three other key managers to leave and start a competing venture before actually submitting their resignation, thereby breaching the heightened fiduciary duties attached to their senior role.
What You Should Know
- Always review the express duties outlined in your employment agreement before signing, paying special attention to clauses restricting outside business ventures or moonlighting.
- If you must refuse a task because it is dangerous or breaches regulations, clearly document your refusal in writing and cite your safety concerns to protect yourself from allegations of insubordination.
- Never take company documents, USB drives, or client data with you when your employment ends, as destroying or removing company property is a serious breach of your duty of confidentiality.
- If you hold a senior or managerial position, recognize that your legal obligations may be elevated to a fiduciary level; consult an employment lawyer before planning any steps to start a competing business.
Featured Cases
T. v. H.
2024 ONSC 3666 (CanLII) · 2024-06-25Employee Confidentiality and Liability Duties
This case addresses the duties and liability of an employee, specifically concerning confidentiality obligations within an employment relationship.
GasTOPS Ltd. v. F.
2009 CanLII 66153 (ON SC) · 2009-09-25This is a legal dispute concerning the duties and liability of former employees and their new company, specifically focusing on the duty of good faith owed by an employee to their employer, involving claims for breach of fiduciary duty, breach of confidence, and breach of employment contract.
D. v. Regional Group of Companies Inc.
2005 CanLII 22133 (ON SC) · 2005-06-23Employee Duties and Liability Case
This is a labour law case concerning the duties and liability of an employee. The dispute arises from the employment relationship between the individual and the employer.
R. v. Doubleclick Email Canada Inc.
2005 CanLII 56219 (ON SC) · 2005-01-13An employment law dispute concerning the fiduciary duties owed by an employee to their employer.
D. v. Royal Shirt Company Ltd.
2003 CanLII 41458 (ON SC) · 2003-10-08Employee Duties: Good Faith Liability
A legal dispute concerning the duties and liability of an employee, specifically focusing on the duty of good faith in the employment relationship.
MTB Canada Ltd. v. F.
1993 CanLII 5585 (ON SC) · 1993-09-03This is a practice and procedure ruling in an employment dispute concerning the fiduciary duties owed by an employee to their employer.
Professional Court Reporters v. C.
1993 CanLII 17488 (ON SC) · 1993-02-11Employment Fiduciary Duty Case: Professional Court Reporters v. C.
An employment case addressing the fiduciary duties of an employee in the context of their employment relationship.
Quantum Management Services Ltd. v. H.
1992 CanLII 7720 (ON CA) · 1992-11-12Former Employees: Unfair Exploitation of Confidential Info
This appeal concerns the obligations of former senior employees who solicited their former employer's clients after departure. The Court of Appeal found that the employees' deliberate solicitation constituted an unfair exploitation of confidential client information obtained during their employment. While non-competition clauses were found unenforceable due to unreasonable scope, the court established that the employees breached their obligations regarding the use of confidential information.
Beyen Corp. of Canada, Inc. v. IMR Research of Canada Inc.
1992 CanLII 15507 (ON SC) · 1992-09-14Employee Fiduciary Duties in Employment Contract Dispute
An employment case addressing the fiduciary duties of an employee in the context of their employment relationship.
B. v. S.
1988 CanLII 10273 (ON SC) · 1988-12-09Employee Fiduciary Duty Case: B. v. S.
An employment case addressing the fiduciary duties of an employee.
Wallace Welding Supplies Ltd. v. W. et al.
1986 CanLII 7626 (ON SC) · 1986-03-06Employee Fiduciary Duties in Employment Contract Dispute
An employment case addressing the fiduciary duties of an employee in the context of their employment relationship.
Genesta Manufacturing Ltd. v. B. et al.
1984 CanLII 2032 (ON SC) · 1984-10-02Employee Breach of Duty: Competing While Employed and Misusing Customer Lists
A case involving an employee who allegedly breached his duty of loyalty by competing with his employer while still employed, copying customer lists, and soliciting customers. The court addressed whether the employee was liable for misappropriating confidential information, using skills acquired during employment, and misappropriating a corporate opportunity.
Regina v. F. et al., Ex parte E. and M.
1968 CanLII 326 (ON CA) · 1968-06-04This is a judicial review or appeal concerning the jurisdiction of an arbitration board and the interpretation of a collective agreement regarding employee obligations. The case addresses whether the common law duty of good faith and fidelity survives a collective agreement and whether employees' actions, such as respecting picket lines or engaging in harmful conduct, violate that duty or the agreement itself.
Protective Plastics Ltd. v. H.
1964 CanLII 198 (ON SC) · 1964-11-24Employee Breach of Duty: Employer Recovers One-Third Salary in Damages
A case involving an employee's breach of duty by using employer resources and confidential information while negotiating with a competitor. The employer sought damages for loss of customers and insufficient performance, with the court assessing damages at one-third of the employee's salary during the breach period.
G. v. H. and F.
1957 CanLII 108 (ON SC) · 1957-05-10Employee Rights to Found Property on Employer Premises
This case addresses whether an employee has a superior claim to money found on their employer's premises compared to the occupier, and whether the employee's status strengthens the occupier's claim. The court determined that the occupier is entitled to ownership of the found money, subject to the rights of the true owner, and that an employee has no right to claim ownership of items found on employer premises.