Ontario Severance

Fixed-Term Contract — Ontario Employment Law

41 casesDecisions from 1916–2025

Lost your job in Ontario?

See the ESA minimum and what Ontario courts have awarded in similar cases.

Calculate your Ontario severance pay

Free, about a minute, no account needed

About Fixed-Term Contract

A fixed-term contract is an employment agreement designed to end on a specific date or upon the completion of a defined project. Unlike indefinite employment—which continues until the employer or employee decides to end it—a fixed-term agreement has a built-in expiration.

In Ontario, these contracts are commonly used for parental leave coverages, specialized IT projects, or seasonal roles. When the agreed-upon end date arrives, the employment relationship naturally concludes. Generally, under the Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA), an employer does not owe statutory notice of termination or severance pay when a fixed-term contract naturally expires exactly as planned.

However, substantial legal disputes frequently arise when an employer attempts to terminate a fixed-term employee before the contract's end date. Under Ontario common law, if a fixed-term contract is broken early by the employer without cause, the worker is typically entitled to compensation for the entire unexpired balance of the term. For example, if you are dismissed one year into a three-year contract, the employer could be legally responsible for paying out the remaining two years of your salary and benefits.

Employers often try to avoid this heavy financial burden by inserting "early termination clauses" into the fixed-term agreement. These clauses attempt to limit the worker's payout to ESA minimums or a specific number of weeks if the contract is cut short. But Ontario courts strictly scrutinize these provisions. If the early termination wording violates the ESA in any way—even theoretically—the clause becomes completely void. When that happens, the employee regains the right to be paid out for the rest of the term.

Furthermore, fixed-term contracts feature a unique rule regarding the "duty to mitigate." Usually, a dismissed employee must try to reduce their financial losses by actively searching for a new job. However, in Ontario, if an employer breaches a fixed-term contract lacking a valid early termination clause, courts have repeatedly ruled that the worker receives the balance of the contract's value without any legal obligation to look for replacement employment to offset the damages.

Another common pitfall involves continuous renewals. If an employer seamlessly strings together successive fixed-term contracts over several years, an Ontario court may deem the relationship to be "indefinite employment" in disguise. In that scenario, simply letting the final contract expire could be treated as a wrongful dismissal, entitling the worker to full common law reasonable notice.

Because the financial consequences of ending a fixed-term agreement prematurely are so significant, the precise wording of the signed document dictates the outcome. Having an employment lawyer analyze your specific agreement and circumstances is the most reliable way to determine what rights and liabilities exist when a contract is cut short.

Frequently Asked Questions

What happens if I am fired before my fixed-term contract ends?

Unless your contract contains a legally enforceable early termination clause, your employer is generally required to pay you the balance of your salary and benefits for the remainder of the term. If they refuse, you may have grounds to sue for breach of contract.

Do I have to look for a new job if my fixed-term contract is broken early?

In Ontario, if your fixed-term contract does not have a valid early termination clause and you are let go before the term expires, you generally do not have a "duty to mitigate." This means you can claim the full value of the remaining term without being legally required to find replacement work to offset the employer's costs.

Can my employer just refuse to renew my fixed-term contract when it expires?

Usually, yes. If a true fixed-term contract reaches its agreed-upon end date, the employment relationship concludes without triggering termination pay or severance under the ESA. However, exceptions exist if the contract has been renewed repeatedly or if you were promised an extension.

What if my employer has renewed my 1-year contract five times in a row?

Courts often view successive, back-to-back fixed-term contracts as indefinite employment. If your employment is deemed indefinite, simply letting the latest contract expire could be considered a termination, meaning you would be owed reasonable notice under common law.

Are early termination clauses in fixed-term contracts always valid?

No. Many early termination clauses are poorly drafted and fail to satisfy all the mandatory minimums of the Employment Standards Act, 2000 (such as specific rules for benefits continuation). If the clause violates the ESA, an Ontario court will strike it down entirely.

When should I consult an employment lawyer about my fixed-term contract?

You should seek professional review ideally before signing the agreement to understand any early termination risks, or immediately if your employer lets you go before the end date. Because a flawed termination provision could entitle you to months or years of unearned pay, legal assessment is highly recommended.

Common Scenarios

  • An executive signs a lucrative three-year fixed-term contract but is let go after just eight months. Because the contract's early termination clause failed to mention the continuation of statutory benefits as required by the ESA, the clause is voided, and the executive successfully claims the remaining 28 months of pay.
  • A warehouse worker is hired on a six-month contract to cover a busy seasonal rush. When the six months are over, the employer thanks them for their service and they part ways. No termination pay or severance is owed because the contract ended exactly as planned.
  • A graphic designer has worked at an agency for six years under twelve consecutive six-month "temporary" contracts. When the employer finally decides not to renew the latest contract, the designer claims wrongful dismissal, arguing that the constant renewals turned their job into permanent, indefinite employment.

What You Should Know

  • Always carefully read any 'early termination clause' before accepting a fixed-term position, as this language dictates what happens if the company changes its mind before the term is up.
  • If you are let go before your fixed term ends, do not assume you are only entitled to the ESA minimums; if the contract wording is invalid, you could be owed the full balance of the term.
  • Keep copies of all past contracts if you are a worker who operates on continuous sequential renewals, as this history is vital for proving you are actually a permanent employee.
  • Because the duty to mitigate functions entirely differently for broken fixed-term contracts compared to regular employment, getting a customized legal assessment of your specific situation is vital before you agree to any severance offer.

Featured Cases

M. v. Enthusiast Gaming Inc.

2025 ONSC 654 (CanLII) · 2025-01-30

Termination of Engagement: Fixed-Term Contract Dispute

This was a summary judgment motion concerning the termination of engagement and entitlement to unvested stock options. The court applied principles of contractual interpretation to determine that the plaintiffs' engagement was not a fixed-term contract, thereby dismissing their claim for damages related to unvested shares.

employment contract fixed-term contract stock options summary judgment termination

Dufault v. Ignace (Township)

2024 ONCA 915 (CanLII) · 2024-12-19

Dufault v. Ignace: Fixed-Term Termination Clauses

This appeal addressed the enforceability of termination clauses in a fixed-term employment contract under the Employment Standards Act. The Court of Appeal applied the Waksdale principle, holding that invalid 'for cause' provisions rendered all termination provisions unenforceable because they could not be severed. Consequently, the employee was awarded damages for the remainder of the fixed term.

employment standards fixed-term contract severability termination clause waksdale principle

Dufault v. The Corporation of the Township of Ignace

2024 ONSC 1029 (CanLII) · 2024-02-16

Fixed-Term Contract: Unenforceable Termination Clause

This case addresses whether a termination clause in a fixed-term employment contract is enforceable when the employer only paid statutory minimums upon termination. The court determined that compliance with the ESA at the time of termination does not cure deficiencies in the contract wording, rendering the clause unenforceable if it did not comply with standards at the time of formation. Consequently, the employee was entitled to wages and benefits for the unexpired term of the contract without a requirement to mitigate.

employment standards fixed-term contract mitigation termination clause wrongful dismissal

Monterosso v. Metro Freightliner Hamilton Inc.

2023 ONCA 413 (CanLII) · 2023-06-14

This is an appeal to the Court of Appeal from a trial judge's decision regarding the early termination of an independent contractor. The employer engaged the worker on a 72-month fixed-term contract but terminated his services without cause with 65 months remaining. The trial judge awarded the worker $552,500 plus HST for the balance of the term and held that he was not required to mitigate his damages. The Court of Appeal decided that the trial judge erred in law, clarifying that independent contractors on fixed-term contracts do have a duty to mitigate. However, because the employer failed to prove that the worker did not take reasonable steps to find new work, the Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal and upheld the $552,500 award.

entire agreement clause fixed-term contract independent contractor mitigation of damages

S. v. The Corporation of the City of Barrie

2022 ONSC 7245 (CanLII) · 2022-12-21

A wrongful dismissal case involving a fixed-term contract. The dispute centers on the termination of employment under the terms of a fixed-term agreement.

employment law fixed-term contract termination wrongful dismissal

W. v. Procom Consultants Group Ltd.

2022 ONSC 6056 (CanLII) · 2022-11-15

The Divisional Court dismissed an appeal in a wrongful dismissal action concerning a fixed-term contract, addressing whether repeated extensions created indefinite employment, whether emails constituted effective working notice, and whether punitive damages were warranted for termination conduct.

contract interpretation fixed-term contract punitive damages working notice wrongful dismissal

T. v. The Municipal Infrastructure Group Ltd.

2022 ONSC 4522 (CanLII) · 2022-08-03

Fixed-Term Contract: Unenforceable Termination Clause & Damages

This is a summary judgment decision regarding a fixed-term employment contract where the plaintiff was terminated without cause before the end of the three-year term. The court found the termination clause unenforceable because it conflicted with the Employment Standards Act, 2000, rendering the entire clause void. Consequently, the plaintiff was awarded damages for the unexpired term of the contract, including salary, vacation pay, and benefits, with the court holding that there is no duty to mitigate damages in fixed-term contract breaches.

damages employment standards act fixed-term contract summary judgment termination clause

M. v. 1845035 Ontario Inc. (McGuinty Funeral Home)

2020 ONCA 816 (CanLII) · 2020-12-17

Constructive Dismissal: Fixed-Term Contract Damages Appeal

This appeal addressed whether an employer's conduct, including removing a vehicle and changing locks, constituted constructive dismissal of a general manager under a fixed-term contract. The Court of Appeal upheld the trial judge's finding that the employer repudiated the contract and that the employee did not condone the conduct despite being on medical leave. The court also affirmed the trial judge's reasonable estimates for calculating damages for salary, vehicle expenses, commissions, and benefits.

condonation constructive dismissal damages employer conduct fixed-term contract

A. v. S.

2019 ONSC 3989 (CanLII) · 2019-06-27

Midwife Contract: Expiration vs Termination & Restraint of Trade

This case concerns the interpretation of a fixed-term midwifery practice agreement, focusing on whether its expiration triggers termination obligations and whether a clause requiring the withdrawal of hospital privileges constitutes an unreasonable restraint of trade. The court applied the contra proferentem rule to resolve ambiguities in favor of the midwife, considering the power imbalance and the non-negotiable nature of the agreement. The court determined that the expiration did not constitute termination under the agreement and that the privilege withdrawal clause was not a restraint of trade.

contract interpretation employment contract fixed-term contract independent contractor restraint of trade

2189880 Ontario Inc. (Burlington Studio Dance) v.

2019 ONSC 23 (CanLII) · 2019-01-02

Wrongful Dismissal: Fixed-Term Dance Instructor Awarded Lost Income

This case involves a dispute arising from the purchase of a dance studio business, which included a fixed-term employment contract for a dance instructor. The court addressed whether the defendant wrongfully terminated the plaintiff-employee without cause after two weeks of employment. The court found no valid cause for termination and awarded the plaintiff damages for lost income.

breach of contract damages fixed-term contract wrongful dismissal

K. v. Procom Consultants Group Ltd.

2018 ONSC 7617 (CanLII) · 2018-12-21

ESA Compliance: Void Termination Clause in Fixed-Term Contract

This case concerns the enforceability of termination provisions in a fixed-term employment contract under the Employment Standards Act, 2000. The court addressed whether a 'Termination for Cause' clause was void for non-compliance with ESA standards and whether this invalidity rendered the entire termination provision unenforceable. The court held that only the non-compliant clause was void while the remainder remained enforceable, and awarded the applicant only ESA minimum entitlements, which were nil due to the short duration of employment.

employment contract esa compliance fixed-term contract severability termination clause

G. v. The Hospital of Sick Children

2018 ONCA 783 (CanLII) · 2018-09-27

G. v Sick Children: Fixed-Term Wrongful Dismissal Appeal

This is an appeal from a trial decision in a wrongful dismissal case involving an employee on a one-year fixed-term contract who was terminated without cause. The Court of Appeal addressed whether the trial judge erred in finding no wrongful dismissal, the quantification of damages limited to the contract term, and allegations of bad faith in the manner of dismissal. The court remitted issues regarding the calculation of damages, mitigation obligations, and a defamation claim back to trial for determination.

bad faith damages fixed-term contract mitigation wrongful dismissal

T. v. Ontario (Children’s Lawyer)

2018 ONSC 2137 (CanLII) · 2018-06-27

Dependent Contractor Status: 13-Year Panel Lawyer

This wrongful dismissal case addresses whether a panel lawyer who worked for the Ontario Children's Lawyer for 13 years under annually renewed fixed-term contracts was a dependent contractor entitled to reasonable notice. The court applied the McKee test, finding that the continuous renewal and economic dependency created an expectation of reasonable notice despite the fixed-term nature of the agreements.

dependent contractor employment status fixed-term contract reasonable notice wrongful dismissal

R. v. Northern Air Solutions Inc.

2017 ONSC 4248 (CanLII) · 2017-09-26

R. v. Northern Air Solutions: Averaging of Hours Appeal

The Divisional Court dismissed an appeal regarding an employment contract dispute involving the enforceability of an hours averaging agreement under the Canada Labour Code and the calculation of damages for a fixed-term contract. The court found that the motions judge's findings on the contractual term were supported by evidence and that technical non-compliance with notice requirements did not invalidate the averaging agreement where no prejudice was shown. The court also upheld the award of damages for the remaining term of the one-year fixed-term contract, including vacation and statutory holiday pay.

appeal dismissed averaging of hours canada labour code employment standards fixed-term contract

M. v. Information Systems Architects Inc.

2017 ONSC 5708 (CanLII) · 2017-09-26

Fixed-Term Contract Termination: Unenforceable Clause

This case addresses the enforceability of a termination provision in a fixed-term independent consulting agreement where the plaintiff was terminated after a client requested a replacement. The court found the termination clause unenforceable due to vagueness, inconsistency, and lack of clarity, interpreting it against the drafter using contra proferentem principles. Consequently, the plaintiff was awarded damages for the balance of the fixed-term contract without an obligation to mitigate.

contract interpretation damages fixed-term contract independent contractor termination

K. v American Iron & Metal Company Inc.

2017 ONSC 4352 (CanLII) · 2017-07-17

Wrongful Dismissal: 35-Year Employee Fixed-Term Contract

This wrongful dismissal case involved an employee with 35 years of service who was terminated under a fixed-term contract. The court upheld the validity of the termination provisions but limited statutory entitlements to post-2008 employment due to valid releases signed by the employee. Additionally, the court found restrictive covenants unenforceable due to broad scope and dismissed the employer's counterclaim regarding breach of fiduciary duties.

fiduciary duties fixed-term contract restrictive covenants statutory entitlements wrongful dismissal

Covenoho v. Pendylum Ltd.

2017 ONCA 284 (CanLII) · 2017-04-05

Appeal Allowed: Void Clause & Balance of Fixed Term

The Court of Appeal for Ontario allowed an employee's appeal in a wrongful dismissal action involving a fixed-term contract. The court found the employer's termination provisions void because they could potentially violate the Employment Standards Act, 2000. As a result, the employee was awarded $56,000, representing the salary for the unexpired 40-week balance of the term, and the motion judge's costs award against the employee was set aside.

damages employment standards fixed-term contract termination clause wrongful dismissal

969625 Ontario Ltd. v Goldstone Resources Inc.

2017 ONSC 879 (CanLII) · 2017-02-06

Termination for Cause: Breach of Fiduciary Duty in Consulting Agreement

This case addresses whether an employer had just cause to terminate a fixed-term management consulting agreement due to the consultant's breaches of fiduciary duty. The court examined whether the consultant's self-serving actions and misconduct justified termination for cause and whether the consultant was entitled to damages for the balance of the contract. The court held that the breaches of fiduciary duty precluded the consultant from recovering damages for wrongful dismissal.

damages fiduciary duties fixed-term contract termination for cause wrongful dismissal

B. v Bausch & Lomb Canada Inc.

2016 ONSC 6307 (CanLII) · 2016-10-13

Wrongful Dismissal: Fixed-Term Contract Damages

This is a summary judgment decision in a wrongful dismissal case involving a plaintiff terminated after three months of employment. The court determined that the written contract and accompanying email constituted a binding one-year fixed-term contract rather than an indefinite term. Consequently, the plaintiff was awarded damages for the unexpired term of the contract, which were not subject to the duty to mitigate.

contract interpretation damages fixed-term contract summary judgment wrongful dismissal

Joss Covenoho v Pendylum Inc.

2016 ONSC 4969 (CanLII) · 2016-08-16

ESA Section 97 Bar on Civil Proceedings & Short-Term Termination

This case addresses whether a civil claim for vacation pay, public holiday pay, and overtime is barred by the Employment Standards Act, 2000, and whether an employee with less than three months of service is entitled to statutory notice of termination. The court determined that Section 97 of the ESA does not preclude the civil action for unpaid wages and that Section 54 does not require notice for employees employed for less than three months. Additionally, the court found that clear termination provisions in the plaintiff's fixed-term contract allowed for immediate termination without further liability.

employment standards fixed-term contract notice of termination overtime vacation pay