Ontario Severance

OHSA — Ontario Employment Law

23 casesDecisions from 1995–2025

Have a question about your own situation?

Ask our AI assistant about Ontario employment law.

Ask a question

Free, no account needed

About OHSA

The Occupational Health and Safety Act (OHSA) is Ontario's primary legislation governing workplace safety. While workers' compensation laws focus on compensating injured employees, the OHSA is fundamentally designed to prevent workplace injuries, illnesses, and fatalities before they occur. It establishes a rigorous legal framework that applies to almost every worker, supervisor, employer, and constructor in the province, enforcing what is known as the Internal Responsibility System (IRS).

The core philosophy of the IRS is that everyone in the workplace shares responsibility for health and safety, albeit categorized by their level of authority. Employers face the heaviest burden, subject to strict statutory duties to provide a safe environment, equip workers with appropriate gear, and implement comprehensive safety policies. Supervisors possess a legal duty to ensure workers comply with safety regulations, while workers themselves are obligated to operate safely and immediately report recognizable hazards. In complex environments like large-scale building sites, the OHSA also designates a 'constructor'—typically the party with overarching control of the project—who assumes critical liability for site-wide compliance.

Enforced by inspectors from the Ministry of Labour, Immigration, Training and Skills Development (MLITSD), breaches of the OHSA are taken incredibly seriously. These are strict liability offences. This means that if an accident occurs, the employer or constructor can be heavily fined or prosecuted unless they can prove 'due diligence'—meaning they took every reasonable precaution in the circumstances to prevent the incident. Recent jurisprudence in Ontario has repeatedly affirmed that simply having safety manuals is insufficient; companies must actively enforce and supervise those standards.

The OHSA is not just about physical hazards; it explicitly mandates that employers create programs to prevent and investigate workplace violence and harassment. Importantly, the Act gives workers the fundamental right to know about hazards, the right to participate in health and safety decisions, and the right to refuse unsafe work. Because the intersection between an OHSA violation, a regulatory prosecution, and an employee's civil rights can be highly complex, applying this legislation to a specific real-world hazard or disciplinary event usually necessitates targeted guidance from an employment law professional.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the basic difference between the OHSA and the WSIB?

The OHSA is a strict regulatory law focused on preventing accidents through safety protocols, hazard reporting, and Ministry enforcement. The Workplace Safety and Insurance Act (which governs WSIB) is a no-fault insurance system designed to provide financial and medical compensation to workers after an injury has already happened.

Can I legally refuse to do work I believe is dangerous?

Yes. Under the OHSA, most Ontario workers have the legal right to refuse unsafe work if they have a reason to believe the equipment, physical condition of the workplace, or risk of violence endangers them. Invoking this right triggers a mandatory, structured internal investigation and, if left unresolved, intervention by a Ministry of Labour inspector.

Are workplace harassment complaints covered by the OHSA?

Yes. Following past legislative amendments, the OHSA strictly requires employers to implement workplace harassment policies and conduct appropriate internal investigations into complaints or incidents of harassment. For deep dives into harassment specifically, you can refer to our dedicated workplace harassment topic page.

What is a 'due diligence' defence in an OHSA prosecution?

If an employer or constructor is charged with an OHSA offence following an accident, they face strict liability. To avoid a conviction, the business must establish a 'due diligence' defence—providing concrete evidence that they took all reasonable steps and precautions to prevent the specific hazard that caused the incident.

Can my boss fire me for reporting an OHSA violation?

No. Section 50 of the OHSA strictly forbids 'reprisals.' An employer cannot dismiss, discipline, suspend, or penalize a worker for acting in compliance with the OHSA or for seeking the enforcement of the Act, such as reporting a safety hazard.

When should I consult an employment lawyer regarding an OHSA dispute?

If you reported a safety concern, refused unsafe work, or demanded a harassment investigation and subsequently faced demotion, lost shifts, or termination, you should seek legal counsel promptly. A practitioner can evaluate whether to file a Section 50 reprisal complaint with the Ontario Labour Relations Board or pursue a wrongful dismissal claim in civil court.

Common Scenarios

  • A municipality hires an independent contractor to conduct road repairs, but a fatal accident occurs on site. The Ministry of Labour prosecutes the municipality, arguing that because it maintained significant oversight and control of the daily operation, it qualified as a 'constructor' under the OHSA and failed to ensure site-wide safety.
  • A logistics employee notices that several towering warehouse racks are severely bent and reports the hazard. When the employer ignores the complaint, the worker refuses to operate their forklift near the aisles, triggering a formal work refusal process and a visit from a Ministry inspector.
  • An office worker reports persistent, severe verbal abuse from a senior director. The company refuses to look into the matter. This failure to launch an appropriate internal investigation constitutes a direct breach of the employer's obligations under the workplace violence and harassment provisions of the OHSA.
  • Following an industrial explosion caused by a lack of proper equipment maintenance, a manufacturing firm is prosecuted. Despite pointing to their employee safety handbook, the court rejects their due diligence defence because management never actually supervised or audited compliance on the factory floor.

What You Should Know

  • Always document your safety concerns in writing to your supervisor or the Joint Health and Safety Committee (JHSC), as an email or written report creates an objective paper trail proving the employer was aware of the hazard.
  • If you exercise your right to refuse unsafe work, you are legally required to remain in a safe place near your workstation during the initial investigation stage; do not simply leave the premises and go home unless instructed by the employer or an inspector.
  • For workers exploring claims relating to workplace reprisals, note that the Ontario Labour Relations Board heavily scrutinizes the timeline of events; retaining an employment lawyer quickly can help secure your legal position before evidence is lost or internal narratives shift.
  • If you are an employer, understand that merely asking employees to sign a manual during onboarding does not satisfy the OHSA; you must actively monitor the workplace and discipline employees who fail to follow the rules in order to establish a valid due diligence defence against regulatory charges.

Featured Cases

Ontario (Ministry of Labour, Training and Skills Development) v. New Leaf

2025 ONCJ 333 (CanLII) · 2025-06-16

OHSA Sentencing: Worker Fatality & Corporate Liability

This is a sentencing decision regarding charges under the Occupational Health and Safety Act (OHSA) following a worker fatality. The court addressed the liability of both a non-profit corporation and an individual supervisor for failing to take reasonable precautions, applying sentencing principles of deterrence and proportionality while considering aggravating and mitigating factors. The court also ruled that it lacked jurisdiction to order restitution or direct fines to the deceased worker's family.

corporate liability ohsa sentencing worker fatality workplace health and safety

Ontario (Labour, Immigration, Training and Skills Development) v. B.

2025 ONCA 426 (CanLII) · 2025-06-09

This is an appeal for leave to appeal a directed verdict of acquittal granted at trial in a prosecution under the Occupational Health and Safety Act. The Crown seeks to challenge the trial justice's application of the directed verdict test and the interpretation of worker obligations, specifically regarding the scope of responsibilities under s. 28(1)(a) and the relevance of private contracts and due diligence.

directed verdict ohsa statutory interpretation worker obligations workplace health and safety

Metrolinx v. Amalgamated Transit Union, Local 1587

2025 ONCA 415 (CanLII) · 2025-06-06

Metrolinx v. ATU, Local 1587 (Appeal Dismissed)

The Court of Appeal for Ontario heard an appeal of a Divisional Court decision that had quashed an arbitration award reinstating employees dismissed for sexual harassment. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, holding that the arbitrator's findings were unreasonable due to errors in principle and reliance on stereotypes. The Court also affirmed that the employer had a statutory duty under the Occupational Health and Safety Act to investigate the incidents even in the absence of a formal complaint.

arbitration judicial review labour relations ohsa sexual harassment

C. v. Peel District School Board

2024 ONSC 4354 (CanLII) · 2024-08-12

OLRB Reprisal Judicial Review: OHSA s. 50

This is a judicial review of an OLRB decision concerning an alleged unlawful reprisal under section 50 of the Occupational Health and Safety Act. The Divisional Court applied the reasonableness standard, confirmed by Canada v. Vavilov, to uphold the Board's finding that the denial of 0.1 FTE was based on the employee's inability to perform essential duties rather than safety-related reprisal. The Court also found that the applicant received procedural fairness during the hearing.

judicial review ohsa olrb reprisal workplace safety

R. v. 1222149 Ontario Ltd. (Dairy Queen and/or Embrun DQ Grill & Chill)

2024 ONCA 543 (CanLII) · 2024-07-08

Corporate OHSA Sentencing Appeal: $40,000 Fine

This is an appeal from a sentencing decision against a corporation for Occupational Health and Safety Act violations. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, finding that the sentencing judge erred by relying on individual sentencing precedents without proper analysis of corporate sentencing principles and by restricting the assessment to the local operation. The court set a new fine of $40,000 plus a victim fine surcharge.

appeal allowed corporate sentencing fines ohsa workplace health and safety

Ontario (Ministry of Labour, Immigration, Training and Skills Development) v. Limen Group Const. (2019) Ltd.

2024 ONCJ 154 (CanLII) · 2024-03-21

OHSA Sentencing: Corporate Fine for Workplace Fatality

This is a sentencing decision regarding convictions under the Occupational Health and Safety Act for a workplace fatality where a worker was crushed by an improperly rigged concrete block. The court imposed corporate and individual fines on the employer and supervisors, applying the Cotton Felt factors and emphasizing general deterrence as paramount.

corporate offenders general deterrence ohsa sentencing workplace health and safety

H. v. Manulife Financial Corporation

2022 ONSC 2350 (CanLII) · 2022-04-19

A procedural ruling in a lawsuit involving workplace health and safety and the Occupational Health and Safety Act. The court addressed motions for leave to bring further affidavits, amend pleadings to increase damages, and compel compliance with undertakings regarding expert evidence and Joint Health and Safety Committee documents.

amendments civil procedure expert evidence ohsa workplace health and safety

Ontario (Labour) v. Miller Group Inc.

2021 ONCA 879 (CanLII) · 2021-12-10

Ontario (Labour) v. Miller Group Inc. - Workplace Injury

This was an appeal to the Court of Appeal from a judge of the Ontario Court of Justice dismissing an appeal from acquittals entered by a Justice of the Peace. The case arose from a workplace accident where a heavy roller went out of control, injuring two employees. The employer and supervisor were charged with workplace safety offences under the Occupational Health and Safety Act. The Justice of the Peace found a breach of s. 11(d) of the Charter regarding the Ministry's inspection of the equipment and excluded the evidence, leading to the acquittals, which the appeal judge upheld. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and ordered a new trial, finding that the lower courts erred in concluding that the defendants had a constitutional right to direct or be present during the investigation, and in granting a remedy without any evidence of prejudice.

charter rights occupational health and safety ohsa procedure workplace injury

United Food and Commercial Workers Union, Local 175 v. Copper River Inn and Conference Centre

2021 ONSC 5058 (CanLII) · 2021-07-19

This is a judicial review of a labour arbitration award where the union challenged the arbitrator's decision regarding the employer's failure to investigate a workplace sexual assault. The Divisional Court examined whether the arbitrator's award of nominal damages and failure to address statutory breaches under the Ontario Health and Safety Act and Ontario Human Rights Code were unreasonable under the Vavilov framework.

arbitration judicial review labour relations ohsa workplace harassment

L. v. Magna International Inc. et al.

2020 ONSC 3912 (CanLII) · 2020-06-24

This is a procedural motion in a negligence action brought by an employee against their employer regarding workplace investigations under the Occupational Health and Safety Act. The defendants sought to strike portions of the Statement of Claim for disclosing no reasonable cause of action, arguing that OHSA amendments do not create a new duty of care, while the plaintiff sought leave to amend. The court also addressed whether additional amendments and evidence filed after oral argument should be considered.

motion to strike negligence ohsa pleadings workplace injury

A. v. Eamon Park Housing Cooperative Inc.

2019 ONSC 6868 (CanLII) · 2019-11-27

Judicial Review: OHSA Reprisal Dismissal Upheld

This is a judicial review of the Ontario Labour Relations Board's decision dismissing the applicant's reprisal claim under section 50 of the Occupational Health and Safety Act. The Divisional Court applied the reasonableness standard and upheld the Tribunal's findings, determining that the employer's actions were good faith exercises of authority and not reprisals for workplace safety complaints.

judicial review labour relations board ohsa reprisal workplace injury

Ottawa Carleton Standard v. F.

2019 ONSC 3899 (CanLII) · 2019-06-28

Workplace Harassment: OHSA Duty in Condominium

This is an interlocutory proceeding involving a condominium corporation, addressing whether a defendant's conduct constituted workplace harassment under the OHSA and breached the Condominium Act. The court considered the statutory duty of condominium corporations to protect workers from harassment and whether an interlocutory injunction should be granted to prohibit the defendant from communicating with personnel.

condominium law interlocutory injunction ohsa workplace harassment workplace safety

R. v. Greater Sudbury (City)

2019 ONSC 3285 (CanLII) · 2019-06-06

OHSA Constructor Liability: City of Greater Sudbury

An appellate review of a criminal prosecution under the Occupational Health and Safety Act where the City of Greater Sudbury was charged following a fatal accident at a construction site. The central legal issues were whether the City exercised sufficient control to be deemed a 'constructor' or 'employer' and whether it established a due diligence defence against strict liability offences. The case later reached the Supreme Court of Canada (R. v. Greater Sudbury (City), 2023 SCC 28). The Supreme Court of Canada dismissed the appeal on equal division, meaning the Court of Appeal's decision stands. The City is considered an employer under the Act and the matter of its due diligence defence is remitted to the provincial offences appeal court.

constructor due diligence employer ohsa workplace safety

R. v. Sunrise Propane Energy Group Inc.

2017 ONSC 6954 (CanLII) · 2017-11-27

Workplace Safety: OHSA Sentencing Appeal

An appeal against sentencing for an employer convicted of strict liability offences under the Occupational Health and Safety Act and Environmental Protection Act following a propane facility explosion that caused death and environmental damage. The court addressed the employer's failure to provide adequate instruction and supervision to employees, the rejection of due diligence and official error defences, and the appropriateness of the fines imposed given the aggravating factors.

due diligence employer liability ohsa sentencing workplace safety

R. v V.K.

2015 ONSC 3639 (CanLII) · 2015-06-26

This is a criminal prosecution of a supervisor for workplace health and safety violations resulting in worker deaths and injuries. The court addressed whether the accused breached legal duties under s. 217.1 of the Criminal Code and the Occupational Health and Safety Act by failing to ensure proper fall arrest systems, and whether criminal negligence under s. 219 was established. The court found that the accused's omissions constituted a marked and substantial departure from reasonable conduct and were a significant contributing cause to the harm, with intervening acts insufficient to sever causation.

causation criminal negligence ohsa supervisor liability workplace health and safety

Ontario (Labour) v. Flex-N-Gate Canada Company

2014 ONCA 53 (CanLII) · 2014-01-23

OHSA Sentencing: Concurrent Fines & Mitigation

This is an appeal from a sentencing decision in a workplace health and safety prosecution under the Occupational Health and Safety Act. The Court of Appeal addressed whether an employer's compliance with inspector orders could mitigate sentencing and whether concurrent fines could be imposed for two separate offences, ultimately ruling that compliance is not a mitigating factor and the court lacks jurisdiction to impose concurrent fines.

concurrent fines employer liability ohsa sentencing workplace health and safety

Terrace Bay Pulp Inc. (Re)

2013 ONSC 5111 (CanLII) · 2013-08-09

CCAA Stay of OHSA Prosecutions: Regulatory vs Creditor Enforcement

An insolvent company applied for a stay of proceedings under the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA) to halt Occupational Health and Safety Act (OHSA) prosecutions. The court determined that the OHSA proceedings were regulatory in nature rather than creditor enforcement, and thus were not stayed under the CCAA or subject to federal paramountcy.

ccaa insolvency ohsa regulatory prosecutions stay of proceedings

Ontario (Labour) v. United Independent Operators Limited

2011 ONCA 33 (CanLII) · 2011-01-18

OHSA: Independent Contractors & JHSC Threshold

This is a Court of Appeal decision interpreting the Occupational Health and Safety Act to determine if independent contractors are considered 'regularly employed' for the purpose of meeting the 20-worker threshold for Joint Health and Safety Committees. The Court adopted a broad, purposive interpretation of the OHSA as a remedial public welfare statute, concluding that independent contractors are included in the definition to ensure minimum health and safety protections.

independent contractor joint health and safety committees occupational health and safety ohsa statutory interpretation

R. v. Marina Harbour Systems

2008 CanLII 64002 (ON SC) · 2008-12-08

OHSA: Constructor vs Employer Definition

This is an appellate decision reviewing a trial judge's findings in a prosecution under the Occupational Health and Safety Act. The court addressed whether the respondent qualified as a 'constructor' or 'employer' with control over the workplace, specifically regarding unloading responsibilities, and upheld the trial judge's reasons as sufficient for appellate review.

constructor employer occupational health and safety ohsa workplace safety

R. v. EllisDon Corporation Ltd.

2008 ONCA 789 (CanLII) · 2008-11-24

OHSA Application to Airport Contractors: Interjurisdictional Immunity

This is an appeal concerning the applicability of the Ontario Occupational Health and Safety Act (OHSA) to contractors and employees working on construction projects at Pearson International Airport. The Court of Appeal addressed whether the doctrine of interjurisdictional immunity prevented the application of provincial workplace safety legislation to work integral to the federal airport authority. The court upheld the application of the OHSA, finding that the appellants' work was not vital or essential enough to trigger federal jurisdiction.

federal jurisdiction interjurisdictional immunity ohsa provincial legislation workplace safety