Court decision
Left your job? Deals you closed still earn your commission

You were paid on commission. You closed the deal, then you left, and the money landed after you were gone. Is it still yours? In June, Ontario's Court of Appeal said yes, unless your contract clearly says otherwise.
What happened
A personal injury lawyer worked 18 years for a Sudbury law firm. From 2006 he was paid a share of the fees the firm billed and collected on his files, nothing on a file until it was resolved by a settlement or a judgment. The deal was oral, and it never said what happens when someone leaves.
In June 2021 he agreed to join a competing firm that October. When he told his firm on October 1, 2021, it ended his job the same day and cut his access. It soon sued him for $3 million and asked the court to declare he had no right to his share of fees on work still unbilled as of February 1, 2021.

What the court decided
On June 15, 2026, the Court of Appeal split the result (W., W. v. P., 2026 ONCA 417).
- Deals closed before you leave are still yours. For files he had settled before his departure, the firm's duty to pay his share survived the end of his job, whether the fees were paid to his old firm or to his new one. As the court recalled from a 1994 decision, a business that accepts and benefits from work done on its behalf must pay for it, unless agreed otherwise.
- Unfinished work follows your contract. For files still open when he left and settled later by other lawyers, he got nothing. His pay depended on the file being resolved while he was there, so the contract itself was the "agreement otherwise", and the court refused to add pay through an implied term or unjust enrichment.
- Planning your exit isn't disloyal. The firm said he broke his duty of good faith in the months between signing with the competitor and leaving. The courts disagreed: he kept billing, did nothing to undermine the firm, and helping find office space was "nothing more than planning for his departure". He was awarded $25,000 for the costs of the appeal.
If you're paid on commission
Read your contract or commission plan for what happens to commissions when you leave. If it says nothing, this decision helps: what you earned before you left is still owed. If it ties your pay to finishing the work, unfinished deals may stay behind.
Leaving for a competitor? Planning is fine. Competing or poaching clients while you're still on the payroll is another matter.
Fired rather than resigning? Commissions also count when your severance is worked out. The calculator lets you add them as other pay.

Browse other commission decisions →
Ontario Severance is independent and is not a law firm. This is general information. From a chat or a calculator result, you can ask us for help finding an employment lawyer, and we reply within one business day.
Sources
This article is general information about Ontario employment law, not legal advice. The law and its application change, and every case turns on its own facts: for advice about your situation, speak with an Ontario employment lawyer.


