Ontario Severance

Professional Conduct — Ontario Employment Law

8 casesDecisions from 1985–2026

Have a question about your own situation?

Ask our AI assistant about Ontario employment law.

Ask a question

Free, no account needed

About Professional Conduct

When standard workplace instructions clash with the ethical obligations of regulated professionals, the legal landscape becomes highly complex. In Ontario, workers such as doctors, geoscientists, lawyers, accountants, and financial advisors are governed not only by employment law but also by strict codes of professional conduct established by statutory regulatory bodies.

A foundational rule in these environments is that a professional's duty to their regulator and the public often supersedes their duty of obedience to their employer. This creates unique tensions in the workplace. If an employer directs a regulated professional to perform an action that violates their code of conduct—such as signing off on substandard environmental data, ignoring a conflict of interest, or misappropriating funds—the employee's refusal cannot legally be treated as insubordination. An employer who dismisses a worker for upholding their professional obligations may face liability for wrongful dismissal, alongside potential claims for bad faith damages.

Dismissals involving regulated professionals also frequently involve mandatory reporting. For example, when financial brokerages terminate an advisor, they must file a regulatory notice of termination outlining the specific reasons for the departure. If an employer uses these mandatory filings to make false or defamatory statements about a worker's professional conduct, it can effectively prevent the individual from ever working in the industry again. Ontario courts have, in specific circumstances, allowed claims against employers to correct false regulatory notices when they cross the line into defamation or constructive dismissal.

Additionally, professionals are often required to report their colleagues or employers for breaches of conduct. When an individual makes a report to a recognized professional college or oversight body (like Professional Geoscientists Ontario or the Law Society), those communications are typically protected by "absolute privilege." This legal principle means employers generally cannot sue the whistleblower for defamation based on the report, viewing the communication as a protected part of the regulatory process.

Untangling the rules of professional responsibility from standard common law employment principles requires careful navigation. As each regulatory college dictates its own statutory framework and disciplinary procedures, scheduling a consultation with a qualified employment lawyer is a critical step to ensure both your career and your livelihood remain protected.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I be fired for refusing to break my professional code of conduct?

Employers cannot legally use "just cause" to fire a regulated professional who refuses an order that would violate their statutory professional obligations. If you are terminated for legally upholding your ethical or regulatory duties, you can likely pursue a claim for wrongful dismissal.

What happens if my employer files a false regulatory report about my conduct?

If an employer maliciously files a false notice of termination or misconduct report with your professional regulator, you may have grounds for a defamation or bad faith claim. However, communications to professional regulatory associations often carry "absolute privilege," meaning specialized legal strategy is required to challenge them.

Does my professional reputation impact my common law notice period?

Yes. Ontario courts calculate common law reasonable notice by weighing the Bardal factors, which include the availability of similar employment. If your professional reputation has been unjustly tarnished by an employer, making it exceptionally difficult to find a new role in your specialized field, a court may award a longer notice period.

How soon should I speak to an attorney if I am under investigation at work?

You should seek legal guidance immediately if your employer suspects you of professional misconduct, well before any formal termination occurs. A dual-threat situation involving both an employer's internal investigation and an external licensing body's disciplinary process is legally complex and requires immediate risk management.

Does my employment contract override my regulatory obligations?

No. An employment contract cannot legally compel you to breach obligations set by provincial statutes or professional regulatory bodies. If a contract attempts to force unethical behavior, those specific clauses will generally be considered void and unenforceable by Ontario courts.

Common Scenarios

  • A financial trader is terminated without cause, but the brokerage firm files a misleading regulatory notice indicating the dismissal was due to unethical professional conduct, effectively freezing the trader out of the wealth management industry.
  • A professional geoscientist detects severe environmental contamination on a project and reports it to their governing oversight body. The employer subsequently dismisses the geoscientist, claiming their communication constituted a breach of confidentiality.
  • A senior associate leaves a law firm to start an independent practice, leading to a bitter dispute where the former firm alleges the departing lawyer breached professional conduct rules regarding client solicitation and unbilled work transfers.

What You Should Know

  • If your employer asks you to perform a task that violates your professional code, document your refusal and explicitly reference the specific regulatory rule that prevents you from complying.
  • Always request a copy of any mandatory notice of termination or regulatory filing your employer submits about you upon departure to ensure the stated reasons are entirely factual.
  • If you are leaving a practice to start your own firm, carefully review your regulatory college's transition guidelines before moving any client files to avoid allegations of misappropriation.
  • Recognize that internal HR departments represent the company's interests, not your professional license; consult an employment lawyer promptly if you face allegations affecting your professional standing.

Featured Cases

Geopro Consulting Ltd v. N.

2026 ONSC 1517 (CanLII) · 2026-03-12

Absolute Privilege in Professional Complaints

This is a procedural ruling on a Rule 21 motion to strike a statement of claim. The court determined that communications made to the Professional Geoscientists Ontario were absolutely privileged and that the action constituted an abuse of process, leading to the dismissal of the claim.

absolute privilege abuse of process professional conduct rule 21 motion strike pleadings

W. v. P. et al., P. v. W.

2024 ONSC 5873 (CanLII) · 2024-10-23

Departing Lawyer Fiduciary Duties & Compensation

This is a civil procedure ruling on summary judgment regarding a dispute between departing lawyers and their former firm. The court addressed issues of professional responsibility, fiduciary duties, and compensation for unbilled work in progress, dismissing the damages claim due to a lack of evidence of harm or improper conduct.

compensation departing lawyer fiduciary duties professional conduct summary judgment

Hampton Securities Limited v. D.

2018 ONCA 216 (CanLII) · 2018-03-02

Hampton Securities v. D.: Defamation & Constructive Dismissal Appeal

This is a motion to the Court of Appeal for Ontario for a stay pending appeal of a trial judge's order. The parties were Hampton Securities Limited, an investment firm, and Christina N.D., a trader. The trial judge found that the employer constructively dismissed and defamed the employee, ordering it to correct a defamatory Notice of Termination filed with an industry regulator. The employer appealed and brought this motion to stay the correction order until the appeal was decided. The Court of Appeal dismissed the motion because the employer failed to establish that it would suffer irreparable harm if a stay was not granted.

constructive dismissal defamation iiroc professional conduct securities

B. v The Centre for Spanish Speaking Peoples

2016 ONSC 7981 (CanLII) · 2016-12-23

This is a procedural ruling on a motion to strike pleadings in an employment-related action. The court addressed claims against individual employees, including lawyers, for actions taken in the course of employment, finding that personal liability is limited to circumstances involving fraud, dishonesty, or tortious conduct.

civil procedure employment personal liability professional conduct striking pleadings

K. v. R.

2003 CanLII 26816 (ON SCDC) · 2003-09-19

A case concerning a conflict of interest within the law profession.

conflict of interest labour law law profession professional conduct

M. v. S.

2002 CanLII 18620 (ON SC) · 2002-10-04

Disqualification Motion in Wrongful Dismissal

This is a procedural ruling concerning a motion to disqualify plaintiff's counsel in a wrongful dismissal action. The court addressed whether a potential conflict of interest existed between representing the plaintiff and the Royal Bank, and whether the City of Thunder Bay had standing to bring the motion.

conflict of interest disqualification professional conduct wrongful dismissal

H. v. Ontario Hydro Corp.

1995 CanLII 7291 (ON SC) · 1995-05-16

Union Duty of Fair Representation & Conflict of Interest

This is a civil procedure motion concerning the disqualification of counsel and professional responsibility issues arising from a labour dispute. The court addressed whether a union-retained lawyer owes a duty of confidentiality or loyalty to an individual union member and whether a solicitor-client relationship exists, applying the test from MacDonald Estate v. Martin regarding conflict of interest.

conflict of interest disqualification labour relations professional conduct union representation

C. v. Canadian Pacific Ltd.

1985 CanLII 2131 (ON CA) · 1985-05-23

Employment Negotiations: Good Faith & Disclosure Duties

An appeal was dismissed regarding a solicitor's employment negotiations with a corporation, focusing on whether the failure to disclose an ongoing police investigation breached the standards of good faith and disclosure obligations required in professional employment relationships.

disclosure obligations employment negotiations good faith professional conduct